Malaysia

#ManaDokumenKami: M’sian mum makes plea for citizenship papers of child born overseas

Woman laments pin-drop silence from National Registration Dept over application status since 2016

Updated 1 year ago · Published on 24 May 2022 7:00AM

#ManaDokumenKami: M’sian mum makes plea for citizenship papers of child born overseas
It was explained that while waiting for the National Registration Department’s approval, Alison Wee was then forced to register her child under the citizenship of her father, a non-Malaysian. – Wikimapia pic, May 24, 2022

by Emmanuel Santa Maria Chin

KUALA LUMPUR – Yet another tale of a Malaysian mother struggling to obtain citizenship papers for her child born overseas has surfaced, with apparently no answers from the National Registration Department (NRD) for the past six years.

Alison Wee, through a video posted on the Family Frontiers’ (FF) Facebook page, pressed on the NRD for answers as to why her daughter, now aged six and whose identity is being withheld, is still not recognised as a Malaysian.

The mother, through the video, claimed that she had gone to register the birth of her child at the Malaysian consulate-general in Naning, China, where she was working as a lecturer and researcher.

“That was submitted in 2016, and now it’s 2022, and she still hasn’t gotten her Malaysian citizenship yet.

“I was in China because I was teaching at a university and was doing good research, and I thought I was making my country proud,” Wee said in the video.

She added that an additional application was submitted to the NRD in March this year.

It cited the high court’s decision that Malaysian mothers have the right to confer citizenship to their children born overseas, on an equal basis with Malaysian men.

However, the federal government has since sought leave to challenge the ruling, with the Court of Appeal set to decide next month if the government should be allowed to appeal against the landmark decision.

“Even with that court order, the process is still taking so long and we are hanging on a line. We are really not sure if my daughter can get her citizenship.

I appeal to the government. Where are our documents? I am a child of Malaysia; my daughter is also a child of Malaysia,” she said.

Sympathising with Malaysian mother Alison Wee’s predicament, Klang MP Charles Santiago says ‘being a parent of a stateless child is scary and frustrating, knowing that the law will not protect your child’. – The Vibes file pic, May 24, 2022
Sympathising with Malaysian mother Alison Wee’s predicament, Klang MP Charles Santiago says ‘being a parent of a stateless child is scary and frustrating, knowing that the law will not protect your child’. – The Vibes file pic, May 24, 2022

Campaign for government to comply with high court ruling

Speaking to The Vibes, an FF spokesman explained that Wee gave birth to her daughter prematurely in China in 2016, despite having planned for the delivery to take place in Malaysia.

“Alison had planned to return to Malaysia to have her child. In fact, she had two prenatal check-ups in Malaysia. However, due to complications in her pregnancy, she gave birth prematurely overseas,” they said.

The spokesman said that NRD had also failed to provide adequate reasoning as to why Wee’s application has yet to be approved.

“No justification, only that the application is still under process,” she said, adding that NRD had also never mentioned if the submitted documents were incomplete.

It was explained that while waiting for NRD’s approval, Wee was then forced to register her child under the citizenship of her father, a non-Malaysian.

However, both mother and daughter are living in Malaysia now, and the mother wants her child to obtain the same Malaysian legal status as she has herself,” the spokesman said.

The NGO then questioned the government’s unwillingness to adhere to the court order favouring mothers with children born overseas. 

She said that the apparent hesitation has led FF to launch their own #ManaDokumenKami (#WhereAreOurDocuments) campaign.

“There is clearly a lack of procedural clarity and consistency among NRD branches and Malaysian embassies or high commissions abroad.

“That is why FF launched the #ManaDokumenKami campaign that strongly urges the government to comply with the high court order and issue citizenship documents to all overseas-born children of Malaysian mothers,” she said.

Explaining further, she said that only six mothers have been successful in obtaining the citizenship documents for their children so far since the court ruling.

Muar MP Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman questions ‘why a child of Malaysia still has not received her citizenship despite there already being a precedent’. – The Vibes file pic, May 24, 2022
Muar MP Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman questions ‘why a child of Malaysia still has not received her citizenship despite there already being a precedent’. – The Vibes file pic, May 24, 2022

Lawmakers Charles Santiago and Syed Saddiq Syed Abdul Rahman have since chimed in, sympathising with Wee’s predicament.

“Being a parent of a stateless child is scary and frustrating, knowing that the law will not protect your child. And, worst of all, not knowing how long it will take for your child to be granted citizenship,” Santiago wrote on his Facebook account.

Syed Saddiq, through a tweet, urged the government to follow the court order and act fast in processing applications like Wee’s.

“I hope and wish for a sound judgement by the Court of Appeal regarding this matter. Mothers should have equal rights to their child’s citizenship,” he tweeted. – The Vibes, May 24, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 3d

Stateless people remain ghosts in their own land, says Anak

Malaysia / 3w

There must be no oppression or discrimination against stateless children, says think tank

Malaysia / 1mth

Harmful amendments remain in proposed move on citizenship in constitution, cautions coalition

Opinion / 1mth

Call for action on government's commitment to gender equal citizenship – Family Frontiers

Malaysia / 2mth

June 25 Apex court hearing on citizenship of children born abroad to M'sian mothers

Malaysia / 3mth

Education Ministry seeking solution for stateless student’s continued education

Spotlight

Malaysia

Perlis MB to 'leave it to MACC to investigate my son'

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Not practical to ban 24-hour restaurants, says lawmaker

By Noel Achariam

Malaysia

Youth not interested in joining political parties, study shows

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Navy reveals names of 10 killed in helicopter collision in Perak

Malaysia

10 years’ jail for woman who threw hot water at Down syndrome man

Malaysia

Defence Ministry opens probe into deadly helicopter crash

You may be interested

Malaysia

KLIA aerotrain to be completed by March next year, says Alstom

Malaysia

Little girl calls for naval mother at funeral

Malaysia

Forest City casino: No such thing, says Anwar

Malaysia

Anwar offers prayers for Pak Lah’s recovery

Malaysia

Sarawak PKR: Time for state to review outdated land laws

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Not practical to ban 24-hour restaurants, says lawmaker

By Noel Achariam

Malaysia

Sarawak family in fight to protect native land

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Talks under way to build Forest City casino