Malaysia

Auditors signed off every vote in PKR polls: Fahmi Fadzil

Communications director says ballot inspectors ready to defend findings if challenged

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 13 Jul 2022 9:00AM

Auditors signed off every vote in PKR polls: Fahmi Fadzil
The election committee itself has recommended to the party’s Central Leadership Committee for results of the elections at divisional, women, youth and central levels to be screened and signed off by the auditor. – The Vibes file pic, July 13, 2022

by Azril Annuar

KUALA LUMPUR – The independent forensic auditors who assessed the recently concluded PKR party polls had gone through every vote, physical or digital, before signing it off, said Fahmi Fadzil.

Speaking to The Vibes, the party’s communications director was addressing a slew of concerns regarding the auditor’s findings, which had ended in some changes to the election results.

Among the issues raised by party members were changes such as Dewan Negara senator Fadhlina Sidek defeating Batu Tiga assemblyman Rodziah Ismail for the Wanita PKR chief’s post.

Also, rapper Syed Ahmad Syed Abdul Rahman Alhadad, popularly known by his stage name Altimet, ended up winning the Ampang division’s top post against actor-producer Datuk Hans Isaac by nine votes.

Stressing that the auditors went through all the votes, he said there were three categories of votes. The first was online voting, which Fahmi did himself.

And then there is voting on tablets, for which there are two categories.

Fahmi Fadzil stresses that auditors went through and signed off on all the votes in all three categories. – The Vibes file pic, July 13, 2022
Fahmi Fadzil stresses that auditors went through and signed off on all the votes in all three categories. – The Vibes file pic, July 13, 2022

“One is that they cast their votes on tablets connected to the internet. And then there are offline tablets, used during voting, but not connected to the internet. 

“After the ballots are over, the election committee staff and those involved in managing the election will sync the tablets to the cloud.

So, the auditor went through all of the tablets, the votes, whether they were cast as online votes or physically on the tablets,” said the party official.

On July 8, newly minted Gombak PKR youth vice-chief Khairul Anwar Rosnan said in a statement that the concerns raised by many party members over a lack of transparency by the JPP were justified.

He had also asked why only the physical votes were audited, while the online votes were not.

Fahmi recalled that during a meeting on July 6, the election committee itself had recommended to the party’s Central Leadership Committee (CLC) that the results of the elections at divisional, women, youth and central levels should be screened and signed off by the auditor.

He stressed that any “results” made by any individual prior to the official announcement by the election committee are nothing more than speculation or supporters’ excitement, and candidates putting the cart before the horse.

And the important thing here is that the auditor is able to sign off on verified votes. Auditors have to sign off on their findings.

“So, in the case of Ampang, as is the case with the women’s chief, the CLC saw that for the auditor to sign off on their report, these votes had to be processed and screened by the auditor.

“So, the authorised official result signed by the auditor is the one that the election committee released on their website. The only official result is the one announced by the election committee,” he said, adding that the auditor was appointed by the election committee and not the CLC or the candidates, as alleged by certain parties.

Furthermore, he added that, like any other professional, the auditors are ready to step up and defend their findings. 

Previously, PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim assured members of the full audit process being carried out by an independent firm, following feedback from its complaints committee panel.

PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has previously assured members of the full audit process being carried out by independent auditors. – The Vibes file pic, July 13, 2022
PKR president Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim has previously assured members of the full audit process being carried out by independent auditors. – The Vibes file pic, July 13, 2022

On July 4, party election committee chairman Zaliha Mustafa said the audit findings revealed that there had been attempts to tamper with the results.

“However, such problems have been identified, and audit experts suggested for us to update our voting records,” she said. “Necessary actions have been implemented following results of the digital analysis.

She also said that the issue did not affect the wins of the majority of central and branch candidates.

The official tally can be viewed here. – The Vibes, July 13, 2022

Related News

Malaysia / 1d

Melaka polls: Voter loyalty, candidate appeal to shape three-way contest

Malaysia / 4d

Anwar cementing full term for the Madani government

Malaysia / 5d

PAS’ partnership with Umno: A double-edged sword?

Opinion / 1w

How a WhatsApp “army” helped flip Brazil’s 2026 election and why Malaysia should pay attention

Malaysia / 1w

Abang Johari urges parties to respect law as Sarawak heads for polls

Malaysia / 1w

Hassan disappointed by ministers’ absence during Budget 2027 debate

Spotlight

Malaysia

Denying young candidates opportunities risks leadership gap in future - Adam Adli

Malaysia

Na’imah’s constitutional challenge over police probe dismissed by High Court

Malaysia

AGC orders further police probe into allegations against Negeri Sembilan MB

Malaysia

PH-Bersatu rivalry puts political understanding to test in Melaka polls

Malaysia

Muhyiddin’s sedition trial dates vacated pending fresh AGC review

Malaysia

Man in his 20s killed in suspected revenge attack in Banting, three arrested

Malaysia

Prosecution to call 25 witnesses in Saravanan’s RM1.097m corruption trial

Malaysia

Malaysia on cyberattack radar, government steps up security measures

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

World

US strikes Iran’s Qeshm Island in latest limited attacks, report says

You may be interested

Malaysia

Malaysia to seek Pakistan's cooperation over 130 citizens detained in suspected scam operation

Malaysia

Anwar: Urban development must not leave ordinary Malaysians, small businesses behind

Malaysia

Police arrest 282 in nationwide crackdown on illegal gambling operations

Malaysia

RM1 million fund to ease healthcare costs for senior journalists

Malaysia

Shuhaily resumes AKPS duties, chairs commanders' meeting after week-long leave

Malaysia

Syed Saddiq questions delay in releasing corporate mafia probe findings

Malaysia

Prosecution to call 25 witnesses in Saravanan’s RM1.097m corruption trial

Malaysia

Anwar says past service record cannot shield Shuhaily from misconduct investigation