Malaysia

Worker accommodation law made impotent by lack of enforcement

Explosion of Covid-19 infections among foreign workers points to insufficient checks at dorms

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 21 Nov 2020 10:00AM

Worker accommodation law made impotent by lack of enforcement
Employers are required to provide each worker with a sleeping area of 3 sq m in dormitories, as well as beds, cupboards and mattresses – all items that cannot be shared. – The Vibes file pic, November 21, 2020

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – In the wake of Covid-19 clusters plaguing foreign workers, industry observers point to the lack of inspections and enforcement at their accommodation as contributing factors.

Malaysian Trades Union Congress deputy president Mohd Afendy Ghani said the recent gazettement of housing regulations is a good move, but enforcement remains an issue. 

In September, the Employees’ Minimum Standard of Housing, Accommodation and Amenities (Accommodation and Centralised Accommodation) Regulations 2020 came into force through the Workers’ Minimum Standards of Housing and Amenities Act 1996. 

The regulations apply to all employers who provide accommodation for their staff.

“The regulation is good as it is supposed to cover all workers in our country. But our biggest concern is labour inspections, especially as manpower is lacking,” said Afendy. 

“At the moment, enforcement agents are multitasking; that’s why we have fewer inspections on worker accommodation.”

Because most migrant workers are not aware of their basic rights or avenues to channel complaints, he said, errant employers continue to get away with non-compliance.

For example, one rule requires employers to provide each worker with a sleeping area of 3 sq m in dormitories. They are also required to provide beds, cupboards and mattresses – all items that cannot be shared. 

The regulations also apply to the foreign workforce.

In August, Human Resources Minister Datuk Seri M. Saravanan told the Dewan Rakyat that the government will not overlook the welfare of these workers.

“Soon, the government will implement and enforce the Workers’ Minimum Standards of Housing and Amenities Act 1996, with all foreign workers in our country given protection with regard to housing and their well-being.”

Most migrant workers are not aware of their basic rights or avenues to channel complaints, resulting in errant employers getting away with non-compliance, says the MTUC deputy president. – The Vibes file pic, November 21, 2020
Most migrant workers are not aware of their basic rights or avenues to channel complaints, resulting in errant employers getting away with non-compliance, says the MTUC deputy president. – The Vibes file pic, November 21, 2020

Adrian Pereira of the North-South Institute, which is involved in human rights, social justice and sustainable development, said housing issues among foreign workers are merely symptoms of a much bigger problem, which may require an overhaul of the country's labour policies.

He said corruption is also an issue that hinders enforcement.

“There are companies that the government has invested heavily in, and companies directly involved in fighting Covid-19. For example, glove makers here were asked by Europe to ramp up production, but did not order them to abide by workers’ rights (law).”

He added that ensuring dorms comply with the regulations also costs money, and the government should work hand in hand with employers on this.

Zerin Properties CEO Previn Singhe said one suggestion is for monies allocated in Budget 2021 to be funnelled for workers’ accommodation inspections.

While the new regulations are a good start, they could still be fine-tuned, he said.

“This regulation is a good start, but it definitely needs to cover more areas, like hygiene and security.” 

He added that the legislation does not cover situations where workers’ hostels are in condominiums or landed properties, complicating enforcement efforts.

“Based on land laws, terrace houses and condominiums are made for residential purposes, and employee dormitories are deemed commercial.” – The Vibes, November 21, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 1w

Penang CM defends move by housing board, says enforcement is last resort

Malaysia / 2w

Saravanan charged with accepting bribe of nearly RM1.1 million

Malaysia / 2mth

Young voters could decide Johor election outcome as parties battle for new electorate

Malaysia / 2mth

PH launches 'Johor For All' manifesto, focuses on jobs, housing and people's well-being

Business / 3mth

Higher diesel prices raise construction costs by as much as 15%

Malaysia / 4mth

PBTs urged to consider rental cuts until year-end

Spotlight

Malaysia

Jokes that hit below the belt: In the race for Malay votes, how far is UMNO willing to go?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

UMNO man says he’s prepared to apologise over ‘joke’

Malaysia

Loke proposes PH presidential council meet on ‘latest political developments’

Malaysia

Sabah leaders condemn priest and nun joke at UMNO PAU

Malaysia

DKU affirms that Tuanku Muhriz is the Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan

Business

Budget 2027 nears final stage with high-impact sectors in focus

Health

Respiratory disease ranks among Malaysia’s top three health burdens

Malaysia

High Court acquits student in Bandar Utama murder case on schizophrenia finding

Malaysia

PAS rejects UMNO call to test political ties through SG4 polls

You may be interested

Malaysia

No motion of no-confidence against Negeri MB, says speaker

Malaysia

PKR women’s wing questions Zahid’s stance on political stability

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

MOF: Nation recovers RM31.3b from 1MDB but still faces RM20b loss

Malaysia

Police fire at tyres after couple allegedly rams officer, URB motorcycle in Kulai

Malaysia

Abdul Aziz’s wide policing experience behind appointment as Deputy IGP

Malaysia

Sarawak only state with unhealthy air readings, Serian worst at 189

Malaysia

Anwar Ibrahim and Malaysia – the politics of hope and fear

By Vinod Sekhar

Malaysia

EC to review electoral boundaries if Sabah, Sarawak get more parliamentary seats