Malaysia

AGC objects to Zuraida’s judicial review seeking declaration as rightful PBM president

Dispute merely internal matter among parties, federal counsel argues

Updated 1 year ago · Published on 12 Apr 2023 1:48PM

AGC objects to Zuraida’s judicial review seeking declaration as rightful PBM president
Datuk Zuraida Kamaruddin, who filed the application on March 24 and named the Registrar of Societies’ is the sole respondent, sought a declaration that RoS’ action to retain Datuk Larry Soon @ Larry Sng as the PBM president was unlawful, and a mandamus order to compel RoS to recognise her as PBM’s rightful president effective October 7, 2022. – AZIM RAHMAN/The Vibes file pic, April 12, 2023

KUALA LUMPUR – The Attorney-General’s Chambers (AGC) has objected to Datuk Zuraida Kamaruddin’s application for leave to initiate a judicial review against the Registrar of Societies (RoS) to seek a declaration that she is the rightful Parti Bangsa Malaysia (PBM) president.

Federal counsel M. Kogilambigai, in her submission, told the high court that the dispute in PBM is an internal matter for the parties to resolve.

“The court has no jurisdiction to hear the matter due to the ouster clause under Section 18C in the Societies Act 1966,” she said.

Zuraida’s counsel, Mohamed Ashmeer Ashrof, argued that the dispute had been settled and a notice was sent to RoS in October last year.

“However, the RoS did not recognise her as the party president,” he said.

After hearing the submissions from both parties, Judge Datuk Amarjeet Singh fixed May 11 for further clarification and to deliver his decision on the AGC’s objection.

Zuraida, 65, who filed the application on March 24 and named the RoS is the sole respondent, sought a declaration that RoS’ action to retain Datuk Larry Soon @ Larry Sng as the PBM president was unlawful, and a mandamus order to compel RoS to recognise her as PBM’s rightful president effective October 7, 2022.

The former Ampang MP, in her supporting affidavit, said she received a letter from PBM on October 27, 2022, informing her about her appointment as PBM president.

However, Zuraida said she had received a letter from the party dated December 19 of the same year, in which Soon declared himself as the PBM president and suspended her membership. 

The former plantation industries and commodities minister said she learned of her sacking from the PBM through The Star news portal on December 27, 2022, but never received any notice, letter or information from the party about it. – Bernama, April 12, 2023

Related News

Malaysia / 1mth

Court rejects Daim and family's bid to challenge MACC probe

Malaysia / 2mth

Penang’s southern reclamation continues despite judicial review application by local fishermen

Malaysia / 6mth

Zuraida slams Dewan speaker for banning use of ‘kafir’, ‘Yahudi’, ‘Zionists’

Malaysia / 6mth

CoA to hear Zuraida’s appeal against order to pay PKR RM10 mil in July

Malaysia / 7mth

Zuraida endorses Dr Mahathir as Perikatan adviser for SG4

Malaysia / 7mth

Do away with by-elections to slash costs: ex-EC deputy chief

Spotlight

Malaysia

Penang mulls raising wages of civil servants

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Court upholds Siti Bainun's conviction, sentence for abusing girl with Down syndrome

Malaysia

After years of delay, Sarawak labour laws to be amended to match peninsula's

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Papagomo charged with sedition, defaming king

Malaysia

Langkawi needs tourists, jobs, not LRT, says Mahfuz

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Sabah hospitality industry offers plenty of jobs but little stability

By Jason Santos

You may be interested

Malaysia

Public sector reform must follow salary hike, politicians say

Malaysia

Single border agency from May 1, says Anwar

Malaysia

Penang mulls raising wages of civil servants

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Papagomo charged with sedition, defaming king

Malaysia

Court upholds Siti Bainun's conviction, sentence for abusing girl with Down syndrome

Malaysia

Technology leading to more young Malaysian millionaires

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Malaysians, not DAP, who questioned PN candidate’s credentials, says Anthony Loke

Malaysia

Papagomo remanded till tomorrow, says his lawyer