Malaysia

Lawyer fails court challenge against MCMC over blocked FB post

In his application to the court, Shamsher claimed that the MCMC had violated his freedom of speech by blocking the post.

Updated 1 year ago · Published on 23 Jan 2025 6:26PM

Lawyer fails court challenge against MCMC over blocked FB post
In his decision delivered via Zoom, Justice Anand Ponnudurai said MCMC's action was not a "decision" that the court could review.- January 23, 2025

A LAWYER failed in his bid to initiate judicial review proceedings against the MCMC over restrictions placed on a Facebook post he published last year after the Penang High Court dismissed his leave application.

Shamsher Singh Thind wanted to quash an administrative request that resulted in users of the social media site in Malaysia being blocked from accessing his May 2024 posting.

The court ruled that the decision to remove Shamsher's post was made by Facebook and not the Malaysian Communications and Multimedia Commission, hence it could not be subjected to a judicial review.

In his decision delivered via Zoom, Justice Anand Ponnudurai said MCMC's action was not a "decision" that the court could review.

In his application to the court, Shamsher claimed that the MCMC had violated his freedom of speech by blocking the post.

He wanted the court to declare the regulator’s actions illegal and for MCMC to drop its “directive” to Facebook calling for the post to be blocked.

"Any recourse, if at all, is against Facebook, and possibly MCMC, in the civil courts," Anand said.

In his post, Shamsher had sought to link the award of a government contract to the husband of a Cabinet minister.

The post sparked intense debate online, prompting MCMC to request that Facebook restrict its visibility.

Shamsher’s lawyer, A Srimurugan, said his client wanted the court to declare that MCMC had no legal power to issue its “directive”.

Srimurugan, who appeared with J. Gunamalar, said that although MCMC's action was referred to as an administrative request, it took the form of a directive.

In written submissions, the Attorney General had asked for the application to be dismissed, saying the MCMC's administrative request was "neither susceptible nor amenable to a judicial review application". - January 23, 2025

Related News

Malaysia / 3d

Najib’s house arrest: Differing views do not constitute treason – lawyer

Malaysia / 3w

13,045 prohibited contents detected on e-commerce platforms, says Fahmi

People / 4w

Malaysian lawyer appointed Chair-Elect of leading global law firm network Multilaw

Malaysia / 1mth

Fahmi condemns threats against UM student over corruption remarks

Malaysia / 1mth

PAS Senator comes forward in defence of Eric See-To

Malaysia / 1mth

Judicial review bid over Tuanku Muhriz's removal withdrawn

Spotlight

World

Singaporean extradited to US over alleged global insider trading network

Malaysia

Malaysia will not bow to external pressure in deepening China ties, says Anwar

Opinion

When those entrusted to defend the country are accused of drug smuggling

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Palace tells Ismail to prove majority support before new exco appointments

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Man who sodomised, killed baby under his care sentenced to death by hanging

Malaysia

Ismail vows to resign if state government breaches undertaking to Tuanku Muhriz

Malaysia

Ismail Lasim to remain as Negeri MB

Heritage

No development at Mount Erskine burial site: land is for cemetery-related purposes

By Ian McIntyre

You may be interested

Malaysia

Police seek public help to identify man found dead in Mount Austin drain

Malaysia

Deutsche Bank handled €21.61m in Jho Low transactions after 1MDB scandal surfaced, MP says

Malaysia

AGC needs declassified Najib pardon board minutes to defend government in court

Malaysia

Failure to assess risks preceded deaths of two workers in Bukit Tagar

Malaysia

Wan Azizah urges parents to step up monitoring as child mental health concerns grow

Malaysia

DAP cannot blame its critics when MPs like Khoo keep proving them right

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Pursue Sarawak’s rights, but do not compromise Federal interests - Fadillah

Malaysia

PH challenges BN-PN to produce evidence or retract royal institution allegations