Malaysia

Standing order? Dewan explodes in row over Muhyiddin’s name

Opposition MPs take offence at direct naming of ex-PM in Parliament

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 22 May 2023 11:51AM

Standing order? Dewan explodes in row over Muhyiddin’s name
Deputy Speaker Alice Lau (pic) in Parliament today. She instructed Gobind Singh Deo to proceed with his question towards Deputy Communications and Digital Minister Teo Nie Ching on government measures to promote digital businesses. – Pic courtesy of Information Department, May 22, 2023

by Qistina Nadia Dzulqarnain

KUALA LUMPUR – The first day of the Dewan Rakyat sitting today witnessed an early morning shouting match after several opposition lawmakers jumped to the defence of Perikatan Nasional (PN) chairman Tan Sri Muhyiddin Yassin (Pagoh-PN). 

The situation in the lower House appeared to become tense when Lim Guan Eng (Bagan-PH) brought up how Malaysia’s position in the Fitch Ratings had dropped when the nation was helmed by Muhyiddin as prime minister. 

“Since the current administration is enjoying political stability for the first time since 2020, I would like to know: what is our main economic policy that will allow us to remedy our Fitch rating, which declined during (Muhyiddin’s) government?” Lim asked.   

Lim, who is also DAP national chairman, said this as part of his additional question to Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim during the question-and-answer session in Parliament. 

Appearing to take offence to Lim’s statement, Jamaludin Yahya (Pasir Salak-PN) then stood up and cited Standing Order 36(5), which states that no MP shall refer to another lawmaker by name. 

“Bagan (Lim) said (Muhyiddin’s) name just now. He cannot say his name like that, he should refer to him by his parliamentary constituency. I’m requesting for him to be ordered to retract his comment,” said Jamaludin. 

After a brief moment of consideration, Deputy Dewan Rakyat Speaker Alice Lau then instructed Gobind Singh Deo (Damansara-PH) to proceed with his question towards Deputy Communications and Digital Minister Teo Nie Ching on government measures to promote digital businesses. 

Affronted by the supposed snub to his fellow opposition member, Datuk Seri Shahidan Kassim (Arau-PN) and several other PN backbenchers loudly protested Lau’s dismissal of the matter, imploring the speaker to at least acknowledge the standing order raised by Jamaludin. 

“A standing order has been cited, the speaker cannot just ignore it,” Shahidan said while pointing to Standing Order 36(6) on how no MP shall impute improper motives against another MP. 

In response to the verbal protests from Shahidan, an exasperated Gobind then jumped into the fray to justify Lim’s statement, explaining that Lim was referring to Muhyiddin’s administration, not the Bersatu president himself. 

“What Bagan (Lim) was talking about is his (Muhyiddin’s) government, not him (personally). What is the problem? 

“We should be continuing with our question-and-answer session (since) we are MPs in Parliament and I would like some answers to my question. Why is this matter being dragged on? 

“Even the one citing standing orders does not understand the Dewan Rakyat rules. Arau (Shahidan), relax,” Gobind said when Arau continued to speak over Teo as she attempted to read out her answer. 

Datuk Awang Hashim (Pendang-PN) also took the opportunity to voice his thoughts on the matter by interrupting Teo’s speech yet again to question Lau on why no ruling had been made on the standing order referenced by Jamaludin. 

Warning Awang that she would evict him from the hall if he went on speaking out of turn, Lau then said: “I already made my ruling (when) I called the deputy minister (Teo) to present her answer. If you (Awang) want to make noise, just leave.”  – The Vibes, May 22, 2023 

Related News

Malaysia / 1d

Speaker informs EC of Subang parliamentary seat vacancy

Malaysia / 2d

Tabung Haji RCI report takes centre stage at special Dewan sitting tomorrow

Malaysia / 5mth

PM term limit: 'It starts with me' - Anwar

Malaysia / 6mth

Dewan Rakyat passes International Mediation Bill

Malaysia / 6mth

Government completes repayment of RM22.45b in overpaid taxes last year - highest in 5 years

Malaysia / 6mth

PM: Malaysia recorded 4.9 per cent GDP growth in 2025, surpassing official projections 

Spotlight

Malaysia

Najib raises objections to 80% of ex-1MDB CEO’s witness statement over hearsay

Malaysia

Tun Dr Mahathir, Siti Hasmah create ASEAN record

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Nanta Linggi to leave Parliament after five terms, may contest new Sarawak state seat

World

Typhoon Dolphin’s remnants swamp Beijing as China braces for more extreme rainfall

Malaysia

Anwar expected to leave hospital today after successful treatment

Malaysia

Husband and wife face death penalty for drug trafficking

Malaysia

Former Subang MP, Wong Chen joins Bersama

Malaysia

Malaysian dies while transiting in Bangkok to Japan (video)

You may be interested

Malaysia

Tun Dr Mahathir, Siti Hasmah create ASEAN record

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Thai officer involved in mid-air disturbance on Malaysia-Bangkok flight (video)

Malaysia

EC: No by-election for Subang parliamentary seat

Malaysia

TH faced risk of RM74.5 billion liability exposure before bailout, Dewan told

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Immigration immediately stops issuing passports with validity periods exceeding 10 years

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Sarawak schools told to halt outdoor activities as haze pushes air quality into unhealthy range

Malaysia

Is reputation worth so much more than a person’s life?

Malaysia

PN walkout over Tabung Haji debate a political misstep, says analyst

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir