Malaysia

[UPDATED] High court rejects bid to challenge constitutionality of vernacular schools

Use of Tamil, Chinese languages in tandem with provisions, it rules

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 29 Dec 2021 10:48AM

[UPDATED] High court rejects bid to challenge constitutionality of vernacular schools
The Kuala Lumpur High Court has decided that the existence of vernacular schools does not go against provisions of the federal constitution. – AFP pic, December 29, 2021

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – Vernacular schools in the country are not against the federal constitution, as the high court here throws out an application challenging their legality over the use of non-national mediums of instruction.

The court also ruled that the existence of vernacular schools, as well as the use of Tamil and Chinese languages in those institutions, are in line with the provisions of the constitution.

Judge Datuk Mohd Nazlan Mohd Ghazali, who presided over today’s court proceedings, dismissed the suit brought by the Federation of Peninsular Malay Students, the Islamic Education Development Council and the Confederation of Malaysian Writers’ Association.

It was first initiated in December 2019.

They are seeking a court declaration that the existence of vernacular schools violates the provisions in the federal constitution, as Article 152(1) defines Bahasa Melayu as the national language.

The group added that Sections 2, 17 and 28 of the Education Act 1966 – which allow Chinese and Tamil schools to conduct their lessons in their native languages – are against the constitution.

Meanwhile, defence counsel T. Gunaseelan told the press outside the court complex that Nazlan had found that vernacular schools are not considered “public bodies”.

“The court held that vernacular schools are not public bodies.

“More importantly, the teaching of vernacular schools does not come under the ambit of public purpose.”

The Malaysian Chinese Language Council, Dong Zong, Persatuan Thamizhar Malaysia, Persatuan Tamilar Thirunal (Perak), Persatuan Gabungan Kebajikan Guru-Guru Bersara Sekolah Tamil, the Malaysian Chinese Language Council, Persatuan Malaysia Tamil Neri Kalagam, Gabungan Persatuan Bekas Pelajar Sekolah Tamil Malaysia, and SMJK Chong Hwa were named as defendants.

Political parties MIC, MCA and Gerakan were intervenors for the defendants, while Parti Bumiputera Perkasa Malaysia intervened for the plaintiffs. – The Vibes, December 29, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 2y

MCA touts poll showing broad support for vernacular schools

Malaysia / 2y

Govt committed to vernacular schools, no plans to abolish them: Fadhlina

Malaysia / 2y

Recent Federal Court ruling a triumph for multicultural Malaysia, says MCA

Education / 2y

Court dismisses appeal to declare vernacular schools unconstitutional

Education / 2y

Using other languages in vernacular schools allowed in constitution, appellate court hears

Malaysia / 2y

Lawyer challenges use of Mandarin, Tamil in vernacular schools

Spotlight

Business

Tycoon Vincent Tan trims BCorp stake further in RM115m share sale

Malaysia

UMNO’s solo gamble in Johor: A show of strength or risky miscalculation?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Nik Aziz’s grandson allegedly slapped by senator: Father ready to take case to court

Malaysia

Lorry driver jailed a day, fined for making obscene gestures, dangerous driving (video)

Malaysia

PKR leader defends MyKhas access suspension for PJ, Subang MPs, cites ‘political choices’

Opinion

Social media set to dominate Johor polls as election kingmaker

Malaysia

Man charged in Butterworth parang attack case that left victim fearing permanent disability

Malaysia

Teen mothers must return to school, says Fadhlina as education remains priority

Malaysia

Penang water tariffs to increase from July 1 after year-long deferment

You may be interested

Malaysia

Trust and transformation: Malaysia - Japan deepen strategic economic ties

Malaysia

MACC officer tells court Penang Tunnel bidder allegedly gained early edge through private briefings

Malaysia

KLIA ‘tout’ van driver detained after allegedly soliciting Indian tourists for illegal airport transfer

Malaysia

Family of five killed as car crashes into water pipe in Serian

Malaysia

Bersama to join the battle in Johor state election

Malaysia

King calls for people-centred development in KL

Malaysia

Police looking for trio involved in violent armed robbery in Penang (video)

Malaysia

Schoolteacher denies multiple counts of physical, digital sexual assault against 2 teens