Malaysia

Sg Muda: Tuan Ibrahim backs Kedah on payment demands against Penang

Inability to carry out logging contributes to ‘loss of revenue’, says water resources minister

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 02 Sep 2022 8:41PM

Sg Muda: Tuan Ibrahim backs Kedah on payment demands against Penang
Datuk Seri Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man says that while he agreed that Penang has the right to draw water from Sg Muda, which flows along the state’s boundary, the river’s origin is at the upstream Ulu Muda forest in Kedah. – Bernama pic, September 2, 2022

by Ian McIntyre

ALOR STAR – Environment and Water Resources Minister Datuk Seri Tuan Ibrahim Tuan Man has apparently sided with the Kedah government over its demand for payment from neighbour Penang over water extracted from the Sg Muda.

At a press conference during the party’s assembly, the PAS deputy president opined that Penang is obligated to pay compensation to Kedah for taking water from the river.

This is despite Penang collecting the water from its own side of the border, along the section of the river that runs between the two states.

Kedah menteri besar and Tuan Ibrahim’s party colleague Datuk Seri Muhammad Sanusi Md Nor has made clear demands against Penang to pay up for the water.

Penang, however, has rejected the notion based on the globally recognised principle of riparian rights, which provides the right to access water resources from one’s own territory, notwithstanding that the water body’s starting point is elsewhere.

Tuan Ibrahim said that while he agreed that Penang has the right to draw water from Sg Muda, which flows along the state’s boundary, the river’s origin is at the upstream Ulu Muda forest in Kedah.

“As Penang wants Ulu Muda preserved, seeing that it’s a major water catchment area, it is only fair that the state pays compensation to Kedah, as the latter is unable to conduct logging activities. It is a loss of revenue to Kedah,” said Tuan Ibrahim.

He was speaking to reporters at the sidelines of the gathering of PAS’ Youth, Muslimat and Ulama wings at the party’s headquarters at Kota Sarang Semut near here.

Tuan Ibrahim added that he has informed Penang Chief Minister Chow Kon Yeow about his stand on the matter.

Penang essentially draws the water at Kepala Batas before channelling it to its treatment plant in Sg Dua, Butterworth.

It is then distributed to its residents on the mainland, and also the island through an undersea pipeline.

Meanwhile, PAS’ women’s wing chief Nuridah Mohd Salleh called on the Islamist party to field at least 30% of its candidates for the next general election from the wing.

Nuridah, a senator, said PAS fielded 39 women in the last general election, but now the wing wants at least 30% of the party’s candidates to be women.

The Dewan Ulama wing, meanwhile, called for the party’ leaders to ensure straight fights with other parties in the polls.

This means working out a deal with Umno under the Muafakat Nasional pact, and consolidating its presence within the Perikatan Nasional coalition led by Bersatu. – The Vibes, September 2, 2022

Related News

Events / 7h

Penang launches STEM-Pulse initiative to help fill shortage of engineers in the state

Malaysia / 8h

Penang: Over 100 PPR tenants face eviction, says exco

Community / 1d

Residents question Penang over delay in completing coastal nature park

Malaysia / 2d

Northern Malaysia must prepare for the consequences of lower rainfall

Malaysia / 4d

Penang’s Air Itam-Tun Dr Lim Chong Eu bypass nearing completion

Events / 1w

Jokowi to deliver keynote address at Peace Dialogue in Penang

Spotlight

Malaysia

Only frame left after Porsche catches fire along LPT1

Malaysia

Steven Sim helps busker raise RM100k for wife's cancer treatment

Malaysia

Selangor declares Oct 25 public holiday for Sultan’s Silver Jubilee

Malaysia

Anwar: Sabah, Sarawak to get higher parliamentary representation under MA63

World

25 years after 9/11, America still lives with the consequences

Malaysia

Najib’s pardon application deferred

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

World

Magnitude 4.1 tremor hits southern Lebanon after Israeli blasts target Hezbollah tunnels

Education

UiTM probes alleged sale of hostel room placements at Puncak Alam

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Documents reveal British royal charity attempted to ‘doctor’ evidence in SLAPP action

Malaysia

MMA asks why FDS aircraft cannot match those used by ministers

Malaysia

Penang-born woman dies in Perth after alleged domestic violence assault

You may be interested

Malaysia

Fuel subsidies or cash aid? Nik Nazmi poll fuels debate

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Ab Rauf: Melaka voters to decide state government’s strategic partners

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Mother and two sons die after being trapped in Kluang house fire

Malaysia

Penang-born woman dies in Perth after alleged domestic violence assault

Malaysia

Penang: Over 100 PPR tenants face eviction, says exco

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Fahmi: 65,280 scam, illegal gambling posts still online despite MCMC takedown requests

Malaysia

Anwar: Sabah, Sarawak to get higher parliamentary representation under MA63

Malaysia

‘We need more healthcare professionals, not corrupt politicians’ (video)