WASHINGTON – Republicans lashed into Joe Biden today over his handling of the suspected Chinese spy balloon, while Democrats defended the president’s decision to shoot it down after it floated across the United States for days, further straining taut relations with Beijing.
With efforts to retrieve balloon debris continuing off the South Carolina coast one day after a US fighter jet downed the large airship, the incident sparked fiery debate over Biden’s dealing with the matter and how US-Chinese ties might suffer.
“As usual when it comes to national defence and foreign policy, the Biden administration reacted at first too indecisively and then too late,” Senate Republican leader Mitch McConnell said on Twitter.
“We should not have let the People’s Republic of China make a mockery of our airspace.”
Marco Rubio, vice-chair of the Senate intelligence committee, said on CNN that the president’s delay in alerting the public to the balloon’s presence amounted to “dereliction of duty.”
He described the overflight as a brazen effort by Beijing to embarrass Biden just before his State of the Union address tomorrow, and to disrupt a since-cancelled China visit by Secretary of State Antony Blinken.
And Representative Mike Turner, who chairs the US House intelligence committee, used a football analogy in blasting Biden.
“Clearly the president taking it down over the Atlantic is... sort of like tackling the quarterback after the game is over,” he said on NBC.
“The satellite had completed its mission. It should never have been allowed to enter the United States.”
Democrats quickly pushed back, calling the Republican criticisms “premature and political.”
Chuck Schumer, the Senate Democratic leader, insisted the administration had “made the right call.”
“We sent a clear message to China that this is unacceptable,” he said in a statement. “We protected civilians. We gained more intel while protecting our own sensitive information.”
The downing of the balloon by an F-22 fighter jet “wasn’t just the safest option, but it was the one that maximised our intel gain,” Schumer said – because any instrumentation on the huge airship was more likely to survive a water landing.
He said the full Senate would receive a classified briefing on February 15.
Another balloon, over Colombia?
Pentagon officials on Friday described the airship as a “high-altitude surveillance balloon,” adding, without elaboration, that Washington had taken steps to block it from collecting sensitive information.
Democrats have argued that Chinese balloons at least briefly overflew US territory three times during the Trump presidency, without being shot down.
A day after Pentagon officials said another balloon had been spotted somewhere over Latin America, air force officials in Colombia said an object with “characteristics similar to those of a balloon” had been detected on Friday and “monitored until it left the national air space.”
China has strongly objected to the shootdown Saturday off the US coast, but whether it plans any further action remained unclear.
In Beijing, the Foreign Affairs Ministry on Saturday expressed China’s “strong dissatisfaction and protests against the use of force by the United States to attack the unmanned civilian airship.”
It added that China reserved “the right to make further necessary responses.”
Beijing has said the balloon was primarily gathering weather data and that it had been blown off course.
Admiral Mike Mullen, the former chair of the US Joint Chiefs of Staff, said yesterday he expected the balloon’s debris would be retrieved “relatively shortly.”
Asked if he thought elements in the Chinese military might have launched the balloon intentionally to disrupt the Blinken visit – the secretary’s first to China since Biden took office – he responded: “Clearly, I think that’s the case.”
Mullen said the craft was manoeuvrable and he rejected China’s suggestion it might have blown off course.
“It has propellers on it,” he said. “This was not an accident. This was deliberate. It was intelligence.”
And Schumer said that once the airship’s presence was widely known, “China attempted to manoeuvre the balloon to leave the US as soon as they could.”
Rubio, in his appearance, hammered at what he said was an ominous message from Beijing: “We have the ability to do this, and America can’t do anything about it.”
He added: “If they’re not going to be able to stop a balloon from flying over US airspace, how is America going to come to your aid if we invade Taiwan, take land from India, or islands from the Philippines or Japan?” – AFP, February 6, 2023
