Malaysia

BRP residents protest plans to sacrifice vital green lung for road

Dwellers want Selayang Municipal Council to halt project, find alternatives

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 11 May 2023 7:00AM

BRP residents protest plans to sacrifice vital green lung for road
Dwellers from several housing areas in Bukit Rahman Putra express their objections towards a plan to develop an access road, which will in turn sacrifice a vital green lung in the community. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023

by Deborah Loh

SG BULOH – Residents of several housing suburbs in Bukit Rahman Putra (BRP) want the Selayang Municipal Council (MPS) and a developer to look at alternatives to creating an access road that will impact the only green lung they have. 

The Save Padang BRP group that they have formed will hold a peaceful protest at Padang Awam BRP at about 8am this Saturday after letters sent to their MP, state assemblyman, the council, and even the Selangor menteri besar were to no avail. 

Save Padang member Munis Muniandy said the protest aims to draw attention to the field and some 80 large, mature trees that must be chopped down to create the access road.  

Bukit Rahman Putra residents put up a banner on the gate of Padang Awam BRP to create awareness about the protest against developers and the Selayang Municipal Council. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023
Bukit Rahman Putra residents put up a banner on the gate of Padang Awam BRP to create awareness about the protest against developers and the Selayang Municipal Council. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023

This is part of the council’s approval given to a developer for a project to build 2,000 apartment units for the 1Malaysia Civil Servants Housing Programme (PPA1M) – in addition to terraced houses and bungalows. 

The construction is expected to add another 6,000 housing units to the area, which already has a population of 24,000, Munis told The Vibes. 

Saturday’s protest is being prompted by red paint marks that appeared on the trees, as well as a signboard on the project near the field that residents noticed two weeks ago.  

The public park and trees are a haven for joggers and those who come for morning qigong and dance exercises.  

The green area also has exercise equipment, a children’s playground, a football field, covered basketball courts, as well as a badminton and sepak takraw court. It has also been gazetted as a green space in the council’s local plan. 

Save Padang member Munis Muniandy (pic) shows a bunting that has been put up on a signboard for the access road project as a protest. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023
Save Padang member Munis Muniandy (pic) shows a bunting that has been put up on a signboard for the access road project as a protest. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023

“About 20% to 25% of the green area will be lost if the access road is created at the perimeter of the park,” said Munis, 54, who has lived in the area for more than 20 years and who is the Save Padang group’s media spokesman. 

“Residents are disappointed that the Selayang Municipal Council is proceeding with the project despite our objections. We just want the council to sit down with us to discuss other alternatives that won’t affect the park.”

No resolution for traffic congestion

The proposed access road would be built on an existing tree-lined pathway that borders the 3.25ha park, which is located behind a secondary school, SMK Bukit Rahman Putra (SMKBRP). 

Munis said residents have also come to learn about the school’s plans for a new car park behind it, which will also affect the park. 

He said a new car park and the access road are unnecessary. Instead, the existing service road between the back of the school and the main road, Jalan BRP 7/1, could be improved with a drop-off/pick-up point and a covered walkway added. This would enable students to walk out to be picked up by their parents or school buses without any need to touch the park. 

“This is just one of the other suggestions residents have, and we want the opportunity to talk to the council about it,” Munis said. 

He also said the proposed access road around the park’s perimeter and behind the school would not help solve traffic congestion in the area, as claimed by the council, and would merely create bottlenecks at various road junctions in the area. 

A screenshot from a video posted by Munis Muniandy on his TikTok account (@coolmunny) on the plans to save the field, which serves as a green lung to the community of 24,000 residents. – Screengrab pic, May 11, 2023
A screenshot from a video posted by Munis Muniandy on his TikTok account (@coolmunny) on the plans to save the field, which serves as a green lung to the community of 24,000 residents. – Screengrab pic, May 11, 2023

“There is no proper planning to ensure smooth flow of traffic,” Munis said, noting that the proposed slip roads are too close to traffic light intersections and that there is limited space for vehicles to make U-turns, while separate residential and shop lot areas will have to share the same entry and exit points. 

Cost-cutting ‘solution’?

Residents also question the need for the access road by the park, as it is about 1km away from the new residential project, which will be on a large tract of Malay reserve land.  

The upcoming project wants to use the main road at Jalan BRP 7/1 for access, and the proposed road by the park is meant to ease congestion there. 

However, Munis noted that Jalan BRP 7/1 is also the only main access for all the housing suburbs in the area, namely, Taman BRP 7/1, Taman Canterbury, Taman Tiara Putra, Taman Tiara Puteri, Taman Tropika Putra, Taman Idaman Putra, Taman Aman Sari and Taman Azalea. 

He said there is a better point for an access road elsewhere for the new residential project that would create a circular flow of traffic instead of jamming up roads in the immediate area, but this would be more costly. 

“It’s obviously a cost-cutting solution for the developer,” he said. 

“The proposed access road (by the park) will only deal with peak traffic during school hours and will not solve traffic congestion on main roads. Why should the park be sacrificed in that case?” Munis said. 

Bukit Rahman Putra residents are dissatisfied since the road project calls for the removal of 80 large, mature trees while offering no assurance that the area’s traffic issues would be completely resolved. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023
Bukit Rahman Putra residents are dissatisfied since the road project calls for the removal of 80 large, mature trees while offering no assurance that the area’s traffic issues would be completely resolved. – Pic courtesy of Save Padang BRP, May 11, 2023

Sacrificing the mature trees that fringe the park will also affect air quality in the locality and the health and well-being of park users and residents, he added.  

Residents have been opposing plans that will affect the park since September 2019, when they were first informed of the project during a briefing by the Selayang Municipal Council with developer Pencala Jaya. 

However, Munis said residents were excluded from meetings on the proposed master plan of the project, including plans that concern the roads in their area. Only SMKBRP and the developer met with the council on those matters, after which residents were informed of the proposed works. 

In remarks to Star Metro on the matter, Paya Jaras assemblyman Mohd Khairuddin Othman was reported as saying that he would listen to their concerns about preserving the park while also taking into account the school’s need to address traffic congestion. – The Vibes, May 11, 2023 

@coolmunny Please save our Padang BRP. MPS please stop cutting 80 beautiful trees that has been here for 25 years. Find a different way. The children and elderly use this Padang for all their recreational activities. #MPS #BRP #SaveourPadang ♬ Calm - Relaxing Music

Related News

World / 1w

Former King Charles adviser arrested under UK terrorism law after Palestine Action protest

Malaysia / 1w

Three new projects expected to spark greater growth in Penang

Malaysia / 2w

Tengku Zafrul: ‘PH to continue expanding economic growth in Negeri’

Malaysia / 2mth

King calls for people-centred development in KL

Opinion / 2mth

Langkawi: An untapped island with much greater potential?

Malaysia / 2mth

Najib’s son joins protestors against high-rise development in Langkawi

Spotlight

Malaysia

Sarawak schools told to halt outdoor activities as haze pushes air quality into unhealthy range

World

Indonesia haze forces schools to close as wildfires intensify amid severe dry season

Malaysia

PN walkout over Tabung Haji debate a political misstep, says analyst

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

51 witnesses to testify at inquest into death of 10-year-old boy found unconscious in school toilet

Malaysia

Female student arrested for allegedly hurting classmate with kerambit at school

World

Colombia quake death toll hits 111 as rescue teams race to find survivors

World

Trump secretly switched to third aircraft in Türkiye over Iran assassination threat

Malaysia

Anwar questions PN’s priorities after Tabung Haji RCI walkout

Malaysia

MACC, police probing TH after RCI findings as govt warns no one will be spared

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

TH faced risk of RM74.5 billion liability exposure before bailout, Dewan told

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Anwar questions PN’s priorities after Tabung Haji RCI walkout

Malaysia

Middle-aged takeover drives Malaysia's cashless revolution as e-wallets shed youth tag

Malaysia

Sabah and Sarawak can become 'kingmakers', determine who will lead Federal government

Malaysia

RM85 billion energy savings in sight as Malaysia rolls out 10-year efficiency plan

Malaysia

11 Sarawak areas hit with unhealthy air quality levels as haze worsens

Malaysia

Police investigate case of knife-wielding woman who damaged vehicle (video)

Malaysia

PN walkout over Tabung Haji debate a political misstep, says analyst

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir