Opinion

Defence minister’s proposition that soldiers engage in vegetable farming is mind-boggling – Patriot

Move would deprive military personnel of the essential training required of them

Updated 4 years ago · Published on 22 Jun 2022 2:00PM

Defence minister’s proposition that soldiers engage in vegetable farming is mind-boggling – Patriot
Veterans group Patriot says that instead of making farmers out of soldiers, Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein is better off if he would turn to address the demands of the veterans that have been in the news recently. – Bernama pic, June 22, 2022

DEFENCE Minister Datuk Seri Hishammuddin Hussein is reported to have said that “every military camp throughout the country will allocate a plot of land for vegetable farming”.

It is not only bizarre but as a retired senior retired military officer of 33 years of service, I find his proposition shocking.

The minister’s logic that this move “would guarantee essential food security for soldiers” is short of scraping the barrel of bankrupt ideas.

His idea presupposes that soldiers will now be burdened with the added responsibility to become vegetable farmers fending for themselves, in addition to their primary responsibility as soldiers – i.e. to train for battle and defend the nation.

The question is, now that the head honcho has made the statement, will the armed forces leadership be willing to uphold it and interpret it as sacrosanct?

We need to also ask to what extent our nation’s armed forces personnel have to be involved in this new vocation.

Will there be a section or a platoon of vegetable farmers formed in each camp site? Will there be a special fund allocated by the minister for this purpose?

While the nation recognizes the urgent need to tackle the current global food security and supply chain disruption issues, the defence minister’s idea will not work well with the armed forces leadership.

This is because formations and units of the armed forces have their own regular training schedule that has to be fulfilled to ensure that their state of readiness is constantly at its peak.

To turn soldiers to become vegetable farmers will deprive them of the essential military training that is required of them, and for which they were recruited in the very first place.

Mind you, honourable minister, farming is not a part-time engagement.

Hishammuddin may have overlooked that there are greater issues affecting the armed forces that he needs to be looking at, especially the state of readiness of the armed forces to deal with any eventualities affecting the security of the nation and the provision of much-needed equipment and weaponry to meet future threats.

This readiness for battle is a phenomenon already affecting the entire world. Surely Malaysia is not operating within a cocooned buffer or are we, so much so soldiers are told to go do farming instead?

The February 11, 2013, Lahad Datu incursion or Operation Daulat should serve the armed forces and the Malaysian police force as a useful lesson that the training of their forces should never ever be compromised.

Has Hishammuddin not learnt anything from this deadly incursion by 235 militant Royal Security Forces of the sultanate of Sulu?

It took our security forces more than a month to defeat the threat which, in hindsight, could have been over in less than a month if there wasn’t so much political interference.

Sir, just recall who was in the news throughout Operation Daulat to get a drift of political meddling.

Instead of making farmers out of soldiers, the minister is better off if he would turn to address the demands of the veterans that have been in the news recently.

The demands are nothing more than seeking what is rightfully theirs within the stipulated confines of the law, and what has been promised to them by past defence ministers and remain empty promises to this date.

Hishammuddin, himself being the defence minister for the second time, is certainly no stranger to the demands of the veterans. But does he have the political will to respond positively to the demands of the veterans? He has yet to prove that he cares for the veterans.

Patriot urges Hishammuddin to reconsider his idea of turning soldiers into farmers and to leave it to the agriculture minister to come forward with a national plan on how to improve food security for the nation.

As the Latin adage goes, “age quod agis” (do what you are doing – concentrate on the task at hand) the defence minister should mind and care about the defence of the nation.– The Vibes, June 22, 2021

Brig Gen (Rtd) Datuk Mohamed Arshad Raji is president of the National Patriots’ Association

Related News

Malaysia / 2mth

PM Anwar proposes ASEAN food security standby arrangement during crises

Malaysia / 2mth

Bangladeshi killed by drunk military personnel was here for holiday with his wife

Malaysia / 2mth

Drunk military personnel crashes into e-hailing vehicle, foreign passenger dies

Malaysia / 1y

LIMA ’25 underscores Malaysia’s commitment to defence readiness, regional peace - PM

Malaysia / 1y

Sarawak to create own Fisheries Department to enhance food security in the state

Opinion / 1y

Food security: Our moral and economic imperative

Spotlight

Opinion

When bullying turns violent, Malaysia must confront what is happening inside schools

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Malaysia-Thailand open historic border crossing to deepen trade, regional integration

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Gerak Khas drama actress, Tisha Samsir denies drug involvement

Malaysia

Student stabbing: Teenage girl sent to Hospital Bahagia for psychiatric evaluation

Malaysia

Anwar wishes Tun M a happy 101st birthday

World

Israel shares intelligence with US over alleged Iranian plot to assassinate Trump

Malaysia

EPF members withdraw RM19.87 billion from Flexible Account as of May 31

Malaysia

Melaka: Student who was allegedly bullied chases schoolmate with box cutter

World

Fresh US-Iran strikes deepen Middle East crisis as ceasefire crumbles

You may be interested

Opinion

When bullying turns violent, Malaysia must confront what is happening inside schools

By The Vibes Says

Opinion

US attacks in the Gulf show the weaknesses of MOUs