Malaysia

Errant drivers fined, but valet companies are not

Technically speaking, ‘it depends’

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 22 Sep 2020 4:00PM

Errant drivers fined, but valet companies are not
City drivers often have to contend with those who double parked – The Vibes pic, September 22, 2020

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – When it comes to double parking, the matter is simple – it is inconsiderate and more importantly, illegal.   

There even have been instances where double parking had resulted in altercations between drivers, resulting in fatal injuries in some cases. 

In some instances, offenders are those too lazy to wait for a parking spot, but it isn’t always the case.

Some offenders may be valet parking services.   

You hand over your car keys to the valet attendant, and he parks the car for you.

If there are no available parking spots for the valet service, the attendant double parks.

When needed, the attendant would move the said car out of the way.

Although it is not a huge inconvenience, it seems like a double standard for offenders.

If individual drivers do it, we get fined. But valet companies seem to get away with it.

The law says no  

According to an AskLegal article concerning double parking, the law that governs the matter can be found in the Road Transport Act 1987.

Section 48 (1) says: “If any driver of a motor vehicle causes or permits such motor vehicle to remain at rest on any road in such a position or in such a condition or in such circumstances as to be likely to cause danger, obstruction or undue inconvenience to other users of the road or to traffic, he shall be guilty of an offence... ” 

The law says if you park a car in a way that blocks or causes inconvenience to another, you are committing an offence that can result in a fine.   

But would this law apply to valet parking services the same way it applies to individuals?  

The answer is ‘it depends’.

It depends on whether the offending valet companies are operating in public areas or their private parking lot. If it is in a private parking lot, they are not subjected to fines.   

“If valet attendants double park in public areas, they are bound by the same laws. In such situations the cars can be fined or towed,” Selangor Traffic Investigation and Enforcement Department chief Superintendent Azman Shariat told The Vibes.  

Car owners get fined, not valet companies  

Azman said the authorities fine or tow the double-parked cars, car owners would have to fork out money.   

But what happens to the valet service? They were the ones who double-parked the cars in the first place.   

“You could sue the parking management, because there’s possibly a contract for services between you and the company,” lawyer Teeruvarasu K. told The Vibes.

He added potential litigants could face obstacles when pursuing such a case.   

“The contract can be declared void in court because it may be for an illegal service, but you get back the money you paid for the ticket.  

“Then, a declaration can be sought from the high court to state that the particular business is illegal. However, this is a costly pursuit.  

“It would be best to just make a complaint at the local council against the valet company.”  

More than just an inconvenience  

“Double parking in public areas doesn’t only cause traffic disruptions but can bring about safety issues.   

“If these valet companies want to do business, they should only be allowed to do it if they have the capacity. If they only have 10 parking bays, they should not take more than 10 cars.   

“They shouldn’t be given a licence to operate if they don’t have the capacity to operate,” said Celia Yeo, who is resident of Taman Paramount Residents’ Association. – The Vibes, September 22, 2020

Related News

Malaysia / 1w

Johor PRN: Over 300,000 outstation voters expected to return

Malaysia / 1mth

Bus driver with 29 traffic summonses arrested on suspicion of reckless driving (video)

Opinion / 1mth

Improvement in making Hari Raya Haji travel more bearable

Malaysia / 1mth

3.3 million vehicles expected to flood highways in conjunction with Aidiladha, school holidays – LLM

Malaysia / 1mth

1.9 million vehicles expected to enter Penang for long holidays starting this week

Malaysia / 2mth

Over two million vehicles expected to use PLUS network starting Friday

Spotlight

Malaysia

After Johor, the uncomfortable question for Anwar’s critics: Were we too impatient?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Network School's business licences revoked, to cease operations tomorrow

Opinion

Orang Asli in Pahang: Token gestures or genuine recognition?

Malaysia

Tuition teacher sentenced to 105 years in prison and 70 lashes for raping daughter

Malaysia

Azam Baki denies involvement in RM178.29 million contract linked to brother’s company

Malaysia

Aminuddin urges NS voters to weigh manifesto promising benefits for M40 and B40 groups

Malaysia

No need to resign, PM has absolute power if there is doubt – Ahmad Zahid

World

Gaza’s water crisis deepens as families face thirst, disease and collapsing sanitation systems

You may be interested

Malaysia

KWAP’s eFishery loss triggers governance review as Anwar backs full investigation

Malaysia

AGC orders inquest into deaths of three men in Durian Tunggal police shooting

Malaysia

Tuition teacher sentenced to 105 years in prison and 70 lashes for raping daughter

Malaysia

Zahid denies BN-PN-GPS-GRS meeting rumours, reaffirms Unity Government commitment

Malaysia

Federal Govt passes RM83.46m in flood mitigation, coastal protection projects to Selangor

Malaysia

Who is Sarah? What we know about the Malaysian lawyer at the centre of the Karim Khan case

Malaysia

Pemudah tightens action against illegal foreign business activities

Malaysia

BN-PH ties strained by grassroots reality, not Putrajaya pact, says analyst

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir