Malaysia

Jailing Covid-19 SOP flouters not the answer, lawyer says

Country’s prisons already overcrowded; adding to inmate population ups risk of coronavirus spread

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 18 Feb 2021 9:00PM

Jailing Covid-19 SOP flouters not the answer, lawyer says
Lawyer Sangeet Kaur Deo says 19% of the third Covid-19 wave in Malaysia involves prisons. – Bernama pic, February 18, 2021

by Rebecca Chong

KUALA LUMPUR – The government must stop jailing Covid-19 standard operating procedure violators given the overcrowding in the country’s prisons, a webinar heard today.

Lawyer Sangeet Kaur Deo said the issue of prison overcrowding has reached a critical stage, and the ongoing health crisis makes it even more important not to add to the inmate population.

“Several prisons in Malaysia are over 200% capacity, while 19% of the third virus wave in the country involves prisons.  

“The most obvious thing is that we need to stop sending SOP violators to prison. 

“While we understand that a message has to be sent for people to comply with the SOPs, sending more people to prison is not the answer, as it just adds to the risk of a potential cluster.

“Alternative sentencing really must be considered.”

Sangeet, who is a member of the All-Party Parliamentary Group Malaysia for the Reform of all Places of Detention, was addressing the G25 Malaysia-organised webinar titled “Covid-19: seeking solutions for prisons and refugees”.

She added that the current system of fines for SOP flouters is not realistic, as many people have taken a financial hit amid the pandemic.

Among the alternatives mooted are a longer repayment period for fines, and imposing community service and a bond for good behaviour.

Lawyer Sangeet Kaur Deo says several prisons are running at ‘over 200% capacity’. – Sangeet Kaur Deo Facebook pic, February 18, 2021
Lawyer Sangeet Kaur Deo says several prisons are running at ‘over 200% capacity’. – Sangeet Kaur Deo Facebook pic, February 18, 2021

Sangeet said Malaysia lags behind other countries when it comes to taking preventive measures concerning prisons.

Indonesia, for example, has committed to allow the early release of 50,000 inmates, with 39,000 having been freed as of last June, she said.

“The prisons director-general has acknowledged the overcrowding problem and has identified over 11,000 inmates eligible for the early release programme. 

“But until the end of last year, only 500 prisoners were released. This is not enough.”

DAP senator and former deputy defence minister Liew Chin Tong urged for a reform of the country’s strict drug laws.

“We need to re-examine Malaysia’s whole idea of ‘war on drugs’ and criminalising drug users instead of seeing them as people who need medical support. 

“Dealing with drug addicts from a medical and rehabilitative perspective would be more effective than treating the issue as a crime. 

“Prison officers have told me that those imprisoned because of minor drug offences may become worse, as inmates are exposed to a wider criminal network.

“Today, we have to start asking ourselves if this war on drugs is still relevant. Does it help reduce drug usage, and is it cost-effective?” – The Vibes, February 18, 2021

Related News

Business / 1mth

Malaysia must give investors clearer exits to unlock ASEAN capital

Malaysia / 4mth

Covid-19 cases in Malaysia stable, no deaths recorded this year – MOH

Malaysia / 7mth

Bad move to channel EPF dividends into Account 3 for festive withdrawals, cautions economist

Opinion / 11mth

A tale of two administrations: How Warisan and GRS shaped Sabah’s future

Malaysia / 1y

MOH closely monitoring Covid-19 amid rising cases in neighbouring countries

Opinion / 1y

The Trump dilemma and reclaiming balance: The urgent need for fair global trade

Spotlight

Malaysia

Bersama suspends Nik Nazmi from party activities for three months

Malaysia

‘We have better things to do than orchestrate khalwat raids’ - Amirudin

Malaysia

Social media posts ‘emerge’- defending Ismail after Tuanku Muhriz’s public rebuke

World

Trump’s Muhammad joke about Iran presidency falls flat at Georgia rally

Health

Haze can cause life-threatening lung inflammation in cats and dogs, vet warns

World

Australia detects deadly H5N1 bird flu on Macquarie Island, threatening elephant seals

Malaysia

Agong warns against using social media to spread hatred, insult others

Malaysia

Nik Nazmi acknowledges he is the individual detained by JAIS

You may be interested

Malaysia

DAP lawmakers’ risk being dropped as party tightens KPI checks ahead of GE16

Malaysia

Cable thieves face tougher punishment as govt targets rail disruptions

Malaysia

Warning: MOF debunks viral poster claiming QR payment charges start on Nov 1

Malaysia

Sarawak election window narrows as December polls loom, says Abdul Karim

Malaysia

Fifty-four missing Malaysians’ families may get relief as Nepal weighs faster death certificates

Malaysia

Bersama suspends Nik Nazmi from party activities for three months

Malaysia

Man found dead with 70 per cent burns beside Johor railway tracks

Malaysia

Target employers and corrupt networks, not just illegal migrants at 224 hotspots - MCW