Malaysia

Discrepancies in accounts of Sivabalan’s death: Santiago

Difference in reporting of time and place of death means police can’t be trusted to investigate themselves, says Klang MP

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 22 May 2021 12:05PM

Discrepancies in accounts of Sivabalan’s death: Santiago
Klang MP Charles Santiago (centre) says the inquest hearing must be made public because this is a case of public interest and the findings must be made public as well. – Klang MP’s Office pic, May 22, 2021

KUALA LUMPUR – There seems to be a discrepancy between the police and family account on the death of security guard Sivabalan Subramaniam.

After visiting the family to extend his condolences, Klang MP Charles Santiago reiterated that Sivabalan’s sister received a call from the police at 3pm saying her brother was seriously ill in Selayang Hospital.

On the day of Sivabalan’s death, his sister had said a policeman told her that Sivabalan died at 12.25pm.

Santiago also highlighted the discrepancy noted in Sivabalan’s death certificate.

“There is another issue: the place of death according to the death certificate is Selayang Hospital. But Sivabalan died at the police station. The report against Sivabalan was also made in 2014 and the police acted after seven years.

“The discrepancies and the police saying that the deceased died of a heart attack less than an hour after he was arrested warrant an investigation and inquest. There is a court ruling that an inquest must be held for every death in police custody.

“We can’t trust the police to investigate themselves. The inquest hearing must be made public because this is a case of public interest and the findings must be made public as well.”

In a short statement yesterday, Selangor police chief Datuk Arjunaidi Mohamed said the post-mortem results showed that Sivabalan died of acute myocardial infarction – in other words, a heart attack.

He added that Sivabalan’s case has been classified as a “sudden death report”, and the full findings will be submitted to the deputy public prosecutor with a recommendation to hold an inquest.

Yesterday, Santiago called for the Malaysian Human Rights Commission (Suhakam) and Enforcement Agency Integrity Commission (EAIC) to initiate a public inquiry into Sivabalan’s death.

“So, here’s the thing. We have had another death in custody at the Gombak district police headquarters.

“For those who may have forgotten, this is the same place where A. Ganapathy died. Yes, the same police station that is currently embroiled in controversy over his death.”

Sivabalan died less than an hour after being taken in at the Gombak district police headquarters (IPD) on Thursday afternoon.

A Facebook video posted on the account of former Tamil radio station DJ Sri Shankar Ganesh, better known as “Funky” Shankar, revealed that the sister of victim Sivabalan Subramaniam claims she was informed by police that her brother was in critical condition at Selayang Hospital about 3pm.
 
She said a policeman then informed her mother that Sivabalan had died due to breathing difficulties and was asked to make her way to the hospital’s Forensic Department.
 
“Till now, we are still unaware of what happened to him except that the policeman had also told me that Sivabalan died at 12.25pm,” she said in the video.
 
Also in the video, the victim’s mother said her son was called to the police station over investigations into a 2016 extortion case.

Sivabalan’s death comes less than a month after the same police station was embroiled in controversy over the death of cow milk trader A. Ganapathy while in police custody.

Ganapathy died in hospital on April 18, more than a month after being taken there from the police station on March 8. – The Vibes, May 22, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 1w

Scam syndicates increasingly organised, like multinationals – police

Malaysia / 1w

Death of Rocky: Individual expected to be charged tomorrow

Malaysia / 3w

MP demands explanation over arrest of two podcasters, questions police consistency

Malaysia / 3w

Police open five investigation papers into Tabung Haji financial issues raised in RCI report

Malaysia / 3w

11 dead, 35 injured during RXZ Members 8.0 event

Malaysia / 1mth

Ayob Khan reminds policemen to uphold integrity, protect PDRM’s reputation

Spotlight

Malaysia

Singapore could bar under-18s from social media platforms that fail safety test

Malaysia

College student dies after falling from 22nd-floor condominium in Setapak

Malaysia

PM praised for ‘Medeka Day’ reforms; More needed to cope with rising costs – Guan Eng

By Ian McIntyre

World

Tupac Shakur murder case ends after 30 years as ex-gang leader found guilty

Malaysia

Unidentified man found dead in Sungai Buloh drain as police probe suspected murder

Malaysia

Four killed, four injured in 11-vehicle Pahang highway crash

Malaysia

Sarawak haze crisis deepens as five areas hit hazardous air quality

Opinion

Would the United States use nuclear weapons against Iran?

Malaysia

Tajikistan eyes bigger role for Malaysia in Central Asian market

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

You may be interested

Malaysia

Four killed, four injured in 11-vehicle Pahang highway crash

Malaysia

RM1b health digital push for faster treatment, better access for Malaysians

Malaysia

College student dies after falling from 22nd-floor condominium in Setapak

Malaysia

3-year-old injured after leg run over by fire dept vehicle during Merdeka parade

Malaysia

PM: Billions spent, but more needs to be done to ease cost-of-living pressures

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

Tour bus crash at Kanowit roundabout in Sibu Jaya injures 23 people

Malaysia

Father found still clutching son’s leg after both drown at Johor Beach

Malaysia

Haze: Emergency only in areas with API of 500, not the whole of Sarawak