Malaysia

Bans on political talks in mosques will hit PAS hardest: analysts

Such places remain central to party for organising grassroots members, spreading messages

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 09 Mar 2023 7:00AM

Bans on political talks in mosques will hit PAS hardest: analysts
Bans by the religious authorities in Terengganu and Perak on politicians from using mosques and surau to deliver ceramah follow similar prohibitions by Selangor and Johor previously. – Wikipedia pic, March 9, 2023

by A. Azim Idris

KUALA LUMPUR – Bans by the religious authorities in Terengganu and Perak on politicians from using mosques and surau to deliver ceramah show moves to curb potentially incendiary and divisive messages, observers said.

While it is a blanket move on all politicians, PAS is likely to be the most affected, one analyst also added.

These moves by Terengganu, a PAS-led state, and Perak, also follow similar prohibitions by Selangor and Johor previously.

Universiti Teknologi Malaysia geostrategist Azmi Hassan said he believes other states will follow Terengganu and Perak, as the last general election (GE15) in November showed some PAS politicians openly spreading hate-fuelled messages that invoked race and religion.

“Like Terengganu and Perak, other states will likely follow suit as they (hateful messages) have reached a dangerous level.

“Mosques and surau are not appropriate places to speak on politics as they are places that are supposed to bring people together, this being the role of religion,” Azmi told The Vibes.

He said that despite preaching about religion, they used the topic divisively to gain political mileage.

PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang has been defiant, saying he will continue to deliver his sermons in mosques. – SAIRIEN NAFIS/The Vibes file pic, March 9, 2023
PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang has been defiant, saying he will continue to deliver his sermons in mosques. – SAIRIEN NAFIS/The Vibes file pic, March 9, 2023

“The sultan, who has power to administer the mosques and surau as well as other religious matters, has no choice,” said Azmi, adding that if left unaddressed, the spread of such rhetoric could create turmoil and unease.

On March 7, the Perak Islamic Religious Department issued a directive prohibiting politicians from giving ceramah at the state’s registered mosques and surau.

The ban in Perak came less than a week after a similar order by Terengganu on political leaders and activists from using mosques and surau to hold political activities or lectures.

Terengganu Islamic and Malay Customs Council governor Datuk Shaikh Harun Shaikh Ismail said the decision was made after obtaining Terengganu ruler Sultan Mizan Zainal Abidin’s assent.

However, PAS president Tan Sri Abdul Hadi Awang was defiant over the matter, saying he will continue to deliver his sermons in mosques.

PAS and the palace

The ban on politicians and activists in Terengganu is significant as it is the only PAS-led state where the religious authorities have made such a move.

It is also significant in the wake of inroads made by Perikatan Nasional in GE15 into other states besides sweeping all PAS-held states, dubbed the “green wave” by observers.

Selangor’s Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah has already decreed through the state’s religious council that Islam should not be politicised and used as political material by any party, especially in Selangor’s mosques and surau. – Bernama pic, March 9, 2023
Selangor’s Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah has already decreed through the state’s religious council that Islam should not be politicised and used as political material by any party, especially in Selangor’s mosques and surau. – Bernama pic, March 9, 2023

In January, Johor Crown Prince Tunku Ismail Sultan Ibrahim issued a prohibition on mosques and surau from being used to spread political propaganda.

In December 2021, Selangor’s Sultan Sharafuddin Idris Shah decreed through the state’s religious council that Islam should not be politicised and used as political material by any party, especially in Selangor’s mosques and surau.

PAS is likely to be the most affected by these bans, said Universiti Sains Malaysia’s Azmil Tayeb, as mosques are central to the party for organising its grassroots members and spreading its messages.

When asked whether the ban in PAS-led Terengganu would lead to a schism between the party and the state’s palace, which is in charge of handling religious affairs, Azmil agreed.

“It’s no secret there’s no love lost between PAS and the palaces, especially after GE15 when the royalty seemed to favour Datuk Seri Anwar (Ibrahim) and his unity government.

“This schism will play out within the state religious authorities tasked to enforce rules, and between the PAS partisans and those who support the palace.”

Meanwhile, Singapore Institute of International Affairs senior fellow Oh Ei Sun lauded the bans, noting how religious sentiments are easily fanned during election campaigns.

“In a multiracial country such as this, it could have disastrous consequences not only for national unity, but for public security as well,” Oh said.

“For the vast majority of the Malaysian population, religion should be separate from politics, and places of worship should not become politicised arenas.

“Hadi is welcome to deliver sermons with religious, but not political content,” Oh added. – The Vibes, March 9, 2023

Related News

Opinion / 12h

A PAS vision for education: Fair chances for all Malaysians?

Malaysia / 1d

Akmal Saleh attends PAS Youth muktamar

Malaysia / 5d

Xavier Jayakumar warns racial, religious politics could erode Malaysia’s unity

Malaysia / 1w

Mohd Amar’s three-year remark puts PAS’ Kelantan record under spotlight

Malaysia / 1w

Zunar slams PAS supporters for ‘stealing’ cartoons

Malaysia / 2w

PN has no right to prevent BN from negotiating with any party

Spotlight

Malaysia

Puteri Umno distances itself from viral Threads post

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

MACC drops orange detention attire for court remand cases after PM’s call

World

Man jailed six years for keeping Indonesian woman as slave in Melbourne home

Malaysia

Emergency declared in Serian as haze reaches hazardous levels (UPDATED)

Malaysia

Haze in Serian enters emergency phase

Malaysia

Death sentence for deaf, mute man who killed family of four upheld

Malaysia

Retired army officer with Datuk title charged with alleged sexual assault of golf caddie

Heritage

Penang first state to recognise Hungry Ghost Festival, cemeteries as heritage

You may be interested

Malaysia

MACC drops orange detention attire for court remand cases after PM’s call

Malaysia

Toying with danger: Police tracking owner of MPV

Malaysia

Former Tabung Haji COO’s charges put off after hospital admission

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir

Malaysia

‘I will quit if Zahid asks me to, not anyone else’ - Asyraf Wajdi

Malaysia

UMNO-PAS ‘reunion’ gains pace as Hadi puts PAS on GE16 alert

Malaysia

Nepal rejects foreign rescue teams, accepts aid after deadly disaster

Malaysia

Retired army officer with Datuk title charged with alleged sexual assault of golf caddie

Malaysia

Child malnutrition needs urgent action, says Charles Santiago

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir