Malaysia

Thomas is wrong about cabinet not having to resign when PM does: lawyer

It is unconstitutional for members to stay on if prime minister loses majority support in Parliament, says Muhammad Rafique Ali

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 02 Feb 2021 4:44PM

Thomas is wrong about cabinet not having to resign when PM does: lawyer
Tan Sri Tommy Thomas says in his tell-all book that he disagrees with Tun Dr Mahathir Mohamad’s decision to suspend his cabinet after he resigned from the top post last year. – File pic, February 2, 2021

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – Tan Sri Tommy Thomas’ suggestion that the Pakatan Harapan (PH) cabinet should have remained following its government’s collapse in March last year is unconstitutional, said lawyer Muhammad Rafique Ali.

In a statement today, Rafique pointed towards Article 43(4) of the federal constitution, which states that, if a prime minister ceases to command a majority in Parliament, he should tender the resignation of the cabinet.

Rafique goes on to say that, on February 24 last year, it was clear that former prime minister Tun Dr Mahathir Muhammad had lost majority support in the Dewan Rakyat, following the defections of Bersatu and PKR MPs to Perikatan Nasional.

“Constitutionally, Dr Mahathir could no longer hold the post of prime minister for the PH administration, where he should have resigned unless the Agong requested a dissolution of Parliament,” Rafique said.

He said when 222 MPs met the Yang di-Pertuan Agong early last year, Dr Mahathir only had the support of about 60 MPs.

In his book, My Story: Justice in the Wilderness, Thomas expressed disagreement with Dr Mahathir’s decision to suspend his cabinet after he resigned from the top post.

He contended that Dr Mahathir’s resignation was personal, and that when prime ministers resign, their cabinet members usually stay on.

Thomas served as attorney-general from 2018 to last year, and said in his book that his resignation was inevitable once the PH government collapsed. – The Vibes, February 2, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 2w

PM to bring Felda forensic audit proposal to Cabinet

Malaysia / 4mth

Cabinet did not discuss Jho Low’s pardon bid, says Fahmi

Malaysia / 5mth

Defamation suit against Najib not meant to destroy him politically - Dzulkefly

Malaysia / 5mth

Frontline services will not be included in WFH plan - Fahmi

Malaysia / 6mth

Cabinet to discuss possible WFH plan for civil servants tomorrow – Fahmi

Malaysia / 6mth

Special Cabinet meeting on Friday over West Asia conflict - PM Anwar

Spotlight

Malaysia

Jokes that hit below the belt: In the race for Malay votes, how far is UMNO willing to go?

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

UMNO man says he’s prepared to apologise over ‘joke’

Malaysia

Loke proposes PH presidential council meet on ‘latest political developments’

Malaysia

Sabah leaders condemn priest and nun joke at UMNO PAU

Malaysia

DKU affirms that Tuanku Muhriz is the Yang di-Pertuan Besar of Negeri Sembilan

Business

Budget 2027 nears final stage with high-impact sectors in focus

Health

Respiratory disease ranks among Malaysia’s top three health burdens

Malaysia

High Court acquits student in Bandar Utama murder case on schizophrenia finding

Malaysia

PAS rejects UMNO call to test political ties through SG4 polls

You may be interested

Malaysia

Loke proposes PH presidential council meet on ‘latest political developments’

Malaysia

Sarawak only state with unhealthy air readings, Serian worst at 189

Malaysia

Anwar receives warm welcome from India’s Grand Mufti at Jamia Markaz

Malaysia

Businesswoman loses RM315,963 in fake projector tender scam

Malaysia

Minister warns against emotion-driven politics amid UMNO exit calls

Malaysia

Family pleads for Nepal SAR to continue as SMART returns

Malaysia

Catholic Lawyers' Society condemns UMNO leader's derogatory remarks

Malaysia

PKR women’s wing questions Zahid’s stance on political stability

By Alfian Z.M. Tahir