Malaysia

Mat Kilau: why be angry at ‘irrefutable’ history, producer asks Sikh group amid criticism

To feature Malay or British soldiers would be ‘deception’, says Studio Kembara director

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 09 Jul 2022 5:29PM

Mat Kilau: why be angry at ‘irrefutable’ history, producer asks Sikh group amid criticism
Mat Kilau, which is Malaysia’s highest grossing film, has collected RM61 million at the box office after hitting cinemas 17 days ago. – Screen grab pic, July 9, 2022

KUALA LUMPUR – The portrayal is based on “irrefutable facts”, said the production company behind Mat Kilau despite criticism over scenes depicting Sikh soldiers being violent with women and children.

One of Studio Kembara’s directors, Abdul Rahman Mt Dali, said there is no need to meet representatives of United Sikhs Malaysia even though the group labelled the controversial scenes as “fictional” and “distasteful”.

“First of all, this is an irrefutable historical fact. So, how do we make a film if we don’t describe it that way? I don’t want to put Malay or British soldiers (in those scenes).

“That would be a historical deception. Everyone has to accept what happened. There is no need to be angry or anything like that.

“If you want to be angry, don’t be angry with us (the Malays) or me, but with the British,” he told Harian Metro.

Rahman said movies are for entertainment purposes, adding that only rational people will not see it as something that can provoke racial divisions or sentiments.

“It’s just like Hollywood. Sometimes what they show is incorrect as well.”

Mat Kilau, which is Malaysia’s highest grossing film, has collected RM61 million at the box office after hitting cinemas 17 days ago.

United Sikhs Malaysia had said the Sikhs, who were British soldiers in the movie, were shown “to have laid hands on old folk, children, and helpless citizens”.

“While the controversial scenes in the movie were fictional, they were distasteful and hurt the sentiments of Sikhs. The Sikh code of practice prohibits laying hands on old folk, children, women, and helpless citizens even during war,” it said in a statement.

The organisation added that the movie shows the spirit of the Malays, who are determined to defend the land, but regretfully portrays members of other races and religions as villains.

Meanwhile, the National Film Development Corporation (Finas) defended its RM1.8 million funding for Mat Kilau, saying that it will not obstruct anyone from releasing films, amid criticism over the portrayal of violent turbaned Sikhs in the movie.

Finas chairman and senator Datuk Seri Zurainah Musa said the enforcement of content guidelines lies with the Film Censorship Board under the purview of the Home Ministry, not Finas.

In a statement, she said Finas provides support via the Digital Content Fund and a conducive post-production environment for the development of Mat Kilau. 

She added that Finas urges creative industry players to be aware of audience sensitivities in this culturally and religiously rich country, in line with Keluarga Malaysia. – The Vibes, July 9, 2022

Related News

Entertainment / 3y

Usher in 2023 with these Buatan Malaysia films 

Film / 3y

Malaysian film industry professionals reflect on the state of the creative sector

Film / 3y

Nominated for 2 movies, will Adi Putra bag the FFM32 best actor trophy?

Malaysia / 3y

M’sia capable of producing films of international standard: Annuar

Film / 3y

Emulate Mat Kilau success: RM150 mil boost in Budget 2023 for local film industry

Malaysia / 3y

Many netizens pan Mat Kilau film after it debuts on Netflix

Spotlight

Malaysia

BN mulls seat swaps in Negeri Sembilan as Tok Mat pushes for election reset

Malaysia

Panther spotted along highway near Tasik Kenyir (video)

Malaysia

Kedah ruler calls for review of Penang lease payments, says current rate no longer reflects fair value

Opinion

When institutions rewrite the rules, we should all be concerned

By Vinod Sekhar

Malaysia

Admission of international students in public universities does not sideline locals – MOHE

Sports & Fitness

Messi reclaims outright lead in ferocious World Cup golden boot race

Malaysia

The hate economy: When division becomes a business model

Malaysia

Driver without licence leads police on 20km chase near Rembau (video)

Malaysia

Puad Zarkashi publicly supports PH candidate in Rengit

You may be interested

Malaysia

“Win or lose, I am still PM” - Anwar Ibrahim

Malaysia

Woman fined RM500 after pleading guilty to criminal force against Perak Sultan

Malaysia

Mother arrested after viral video shows children standing through moving car sunroof

Malaysia

Anwar to Johor leadership: Do not let mega projects overshadow grassroots needs

Malaysia

Zahid rejects betrayal accusations as BN launches solo campaign to defend Johor

Malaysia

Groups demand mandatory criminal background checks and revamp of sex offender registry

Malaysia

Jana Wibawa trial: Tengku Zafrul arrives at KL High Court

Malaysia

Two Indonesian women killed after SUV crashes into school surau in Pasir Puteh