Malaysia

Kamunting camp should be heritage site like Mandela’s Robben Island: S’gor lawmaker

Saari Sungib proposes to honour detainees, including PM10, who were held there

Updated 3 years ago · Published on 30 Nov 2022 8:00AM

Kamunting camp should be heritage site like Mandela’s Robben Island: S’gor lawmaker
Saari Sungib, the Hulu Kelang assemblyman, suggests for the infamous Kamunting Detention Camp to be turned into a heritage and tourist attraction site, in the same vein that Robben Island, where South Africa’s Nelson Mandela was imprisoned on, has become. – Bakhtiar Yusoff Facebook pic, November 30, 2022

by Shahrim Tamrin

SHAH ALAM – A Selangor lawmaker has called for the infamous Kamunting Detention Camp to be turned into a heritage and tourist attraction site, in the same vein that Robben Island, where South Africa’s Nelson Mandela was imprisoned, has become. 

Reading his open letter containing 11 wishes to new Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim, Hulu Kelang assemblyman Saari Sungib highlighted, among others, the potential that Kamunting rehabilitation camp can offer.

Hulu Kelang assemblyman Saari Sungib has highlighted the potential that Kamunting rehabilitation camp can offer if it were to be turned into a heritage and tourist attraction site, commemorating the oppression and sufferings of the detainees there. He was also one of the people who were detained at the camp. – Saari Sungib Facebook pic, November 30, 2022
Hulu Kelang assemblyman Saari Sungib has highlighted the potential that Kamunting rehabilitation camp can offer if it were to be turned into a heritage and tourist attraction site, commemorating the oppression and sufferings of the detainees there. He was also one of the people who were detained at the camp. – Saari Sungib Facebook pic, November 30, 2022

He said the camp in Taiping, Perak, has the potential to be a heritage site, “similar to the prison camp of Robben Island in South Africa.”

The prison in Robben Island is situated 7.4km north of Cape Town and it is a renowned place in which Mandela, a former South African president and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, endured for 18 years fighting against apartheid.

The island was turned into a museum in 1997 and two years later, it was declared a national monument and received designation as a Unesco World Heritage site.

Saari, who was twice detained without trial himself, also called for the release of all political prisoners, including those at the Kamunting and Simpang Renggam camps.

“Today, Robben Island is a tourist attraction. So it is clear that the Kamunting camp can be turned into a world heritage site to commemorate the oppression and sufferings that have preyed on tens of thousands of Malaysians,” said Saari at the Selangor assembly yesterday.

He urged the prime minister not to forget the dark days experienced by detainees and political prisoners under the Internal Security Act (ISA) many years ago.

The prison in Robben Island is situated 7.4km north of Cape Town and it is a renowned place in which Mandela, a former prime minister and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, endured for 18 years fighting against apartheid. – Wikipedia pic, November 30, 2022
The prison in Robben Island is situated 7.4km north of Cape Town and it is a renowned place in which Mandela, a former prime minister and Nobel Peace Prize laureate, endured for 18 years fighting against apartheid. – Wikipedia pic, November 30, 2022

“Other than a symbol of political struggle and oppression in our nation’s history, the camp has the potential to be a tourist attraction and could generate a lot of economic spinoffs just like Robben Island,” said Saari.

It is reported that Robben Island has received more than 200,000 visitors annually since it was opened as a tourist site.

He cited a study by a University of London doctoral student and findings by Human Rights Watch that tens of thousands of detainees inhabited the camp for many years.

Saari was arrested under ISA in 1998 and again in 2001, and was kept detained until 2003. He was declared as a political prisoner by Human Rights Watch and a prisoner of conscience by Amnesty International.

In 2016, Saari, together with four other ISA detainees including former Batu MP Tian Chua, activist Hishamuddin Rais and Badaruddin Ismail and former PKR central leadership council member Badrul Amin Baharom, were awarded RM5.16 million in compensation by the Court of Appeal after suing the government for unlawful detention.

In 2011, Saari released a book “Kamunting Camp Torment: Life story under ISA” (Sengsara Kem Kamunting) in which he described the interrogation technique in Kamunting as paralleling the CIA methods of grilling Guantanamo detainees.

He also wrote a few other books about his ordeal at the Kamunting Camp which include “Unlawful Detention & Mala Fide” (Penahanan Tidak Sah & Mala Fide) and “Suffering in Prison Without Trial” (Derita Penjara Tanpa Bicara).

Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim was detained under ISA and sent to Kamunting camp for 20 months in 1974 due to his involvement in fighting for poor Kedah farmers’ plight and against poverty in a series of demonstrations held in Kuala Lumpur back then. – Reformasi Perjuangan Diteruskan book pic, November 30, 2022
Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim was detained under ISA and sent to Kamunting camp for 20 months in 1974 due to his involvement in fighting for poor Kedah farmers’ plight and against poverty in a series of demonstrations held in Kuala Lumpur back then. – Reformasi Perjuangan Diteruskan book pic, November 30, 2022

Recalling the pain, the Hulu Kelang representative said he will not forget the daily mental torture and vulgarities from the interrogation officers at the camp.

“Thus, I would like to ask our prime minister to release all political prisoners as soon as possible including those in Kamunting and Simpang Renggam currently,” he said, adding that it would augur well for Malaysia’s human rights standing.

Anwar was detained under ISA and sent to Kamunting Camp for 20 months in 1974 due to his involvement in fighting for poor Kedah farmers’ plight and against poverty in a series of demonstrations held in Kuala Lumpur back then. – The Vibes, November 30, 2022

Related News

Opinion / 2mth

A civilizational moment for Malaysia: From Al-Attas to Osman Bakar

Opinion / 4mth

Government Procurement Bill 2025: Evidence of government’s firm stance against corruption

Malaysia / 7mth

 PM’s claim of compliance on Sabah’s 40% share conflicts with court ruling, says Roger Chin

Malaysia / 7mth

Nation on right track towards economic objectives, say economists

Events / 7mth

Global leaders, thinkers, and advocates from across the Global South in KL for three-day conference

Opinion / 7mth

Madani Budget 2026: A budget of direction, not perfection

Spotlight

Malaysia

Former head of a ministry's corporate communications unit acquitted of bribery charge

Malaysia

Two sisters die trapped in Johor house fire as escape routes cut off by flames

Malaysia

NS election speculation intensifies as Aminuddin granted audience with state ruler

Malaysia

Teenager who drove recklessly, causing death remanded for further investigation

Malaysia

Police looking for trio involved in violent armed robbery in Penang (video)

Malaysia

Family of five killed as car crashes into water pipe in Serian

Malaysia

'I was once spat on by a pakcik' — Marina denies fear of contesting Malay-majority seats

Malaysia

Jewellery shop among six premises destroyed in fire (video)

You may be interested

Malaysia

Two sisters die trapped in Johor house fire as escape routes cut off by flames

Malaysia

JPJ probes couple ‘manja’ incident in car, summons to be issued (video)

Malaysia

Former head of a ministry's corporate communications unit acquitted of bribery charge

Malaysia

Malaysia emerges as lucrative base for transnational scam syndicates, claims NGO

Malaysia

Govt prioritises effective administration over early election talk - Anwar

Malaysia

‘What wrong did I do?’ – asks PKR MP after loss of MyKhas access

Malaysia

Jewellery shop among six premises destroyed in fire (video)

Malaysia

No early Penang polls as state prioritises voters’ mandate over electoral synchronisation

By Ian McIntyre