Malaysia

Quarrying fears at Gunung Kanthan geopark fuel anxiety at yet another cultural site

Land lease awarded to mining company Alam Jayamas despite Hindu temple’s application for temporary occupation

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 14 Jun 2021 7:00AM

Quarrying fears at Gunung Kanthan geopark fuel anxiety at yet another cultural site
The Kanthan Sri Kallumalai Maha Kaliamman Temple has been registered with the Registrar of Societies since the 1970s, says a spokesman. – File pic, June 14, 2021

by Arjun Mohanakrishnan

KUALA LUMPUR – The prospect of fresh quarrying activities at Gunung Kanthan, an ecologically diverse hill in the Kinta Valley National Geopark in Perak, has triggered alarm on the fate of yet another cultural site there.

The community at the Kanthan Sri Kallumalai Maha Kaliamman Temple has been hit with anxiety over the Perak government’s decision to award a lease for the land on which the temple sits to a quarrying company.

A temple spokesman, who wished to remain anonymous, said the temple has been registered with the Registrar of Societies (RoS) since the 1970s.

He said the temple filed an application for a temporary occupation licence (TOL) in March last year, but the application was rejected and the lease awarded to Alam Jayamas Sdn Bhd instead.

According to documents sighted by The Vibes, Alam Jayamas’ mining lease was registered on July 21 last year, and only expires in 30 years.

The annual rent of the lease is valued at RM1,308.

“We applied for the TOL first. So, why did the state government give the lease to Alam Jayamas?” the temple spokesman told The Vibes.

In an email to The Vibes, Alam Jayamas spokesman Michelle Low confirmed that the company is the leaseholder of the land where the temple is sited.

She said the firm has yet to engage with the committee or representatives of the temple, and plans to do so after the movement control order (MCO) is over, when the situation permits.

“We hope that all those involved will respect and abide by the law.”

The Kanthan Sri Kallumalai Maha Kaliamman Temple temple sits on Gunung Kanthan, a limestone hill upon which the Sakyamuni Caves Buddhist Monastery, which is facing possible eviction, is also located. – Screen grab, June 14, 2021
The Kanthan Sri Kallumalai Maha Kaliamman Temple temple sits on Gunung Kanthan, a limestone hill upon which the Sakyamuni Caves Buddhist Monastery, which is facing possible eviction, is also located. – Screen grab, June 14, 2021

Not fully protected

The Hindu temple sits on Gunung Kanthan, a limestone hill upon which the Sakyamuni Caves Buddhist Monastery is also located.

However, Sakyamuni, on the opposite side of the hill, faces being evicted by a cement company also involved in quarrying activities.

Gunung Kanthan is in the Lembah Kinta Geopark, which is administered by the Perak State Parks Corporation (PSPC).

Geopark officer Ain Maisyara Yazrol had told The Vibes that, despite the geopark status, the hill does not have the same protection as state parks under the law.

“The geopark is under the PSPC’s purview, but we lack enforcement and laws that exist for state parks,” she said. 

“So, the geopark is still subject to the (decisions of the) owner (leaseholder) of the land.”

The geopark office has advised the Sakyamuni monastery to apply to be designated a cultural heritage site.

Meanwhile, a Sri Kallumalai temple spokesman said its devotees and management are worried they may soon face the same fate in being evicted, although Alam Jayamas has yet to take any action against the Hindu temple.

An Alam Jayamas representative, meanwhile, told The Vibes that its office is temporarily closed and that directors familiar with the matter are unable to respond as they are held up in zones under an enhanced MCO (EMCO).

The representative said Alam Jayamas will respond on the matter by Monday.

The Siddharta Gautama statue with his hands on his knees, palms facing down, at the Sakyamuni Cave Monastery. – File pic, June 14, 2021
The Siddharta Gautama statue with his hands on his knees, palms facing down, at the Sakyamuni Cave Monastery. – File pic, June 14, 2021

Grave threat

Meanwhile, Muhamad Arafat Varisai Mahamad, the assemblyman for Hulu Kinta, the state constituency that covers Gunung Kanthan, said that he is against the decision to award the lease to the company.

“I want to make my stand clear: I am against this and I will discuss this with the menteri besar,” he said.

“During that time in 2020 (when the lease was awarded), there was a different menteri besar,” he told The Vibes.

He said the lease should not have been awarded, given that the temple has been there for so long, but will enquire if the lease was awarded subject to any terms relevant to the temple.

“I know the chairman of the temple and, within the soonest time, I will discuss the matter with them.

“If the government gave (Alam Jayamas) the lease only recently, I don’t agree,” Arafat added. 

Environmental groups have warned that expanding quarrying operations at Gunung Kanthan poses a grave threat to the area’s endemic flora and fauna.

NGOs, including Sahabat Alam Malaysia, Sahabat Alam Activists’ Association, Perak Natural Heritage Geopark Tour Guides’ Association and Kinta Valley Watch, have jointly expressed concern about the risk to various species at the Perak geopark. – The Vibes, June 14, 2021

Related News

Malaysia / 2w

Penang signs landmark Perak water deal to secure 40-year supply from 2032

Malaysia / 3mth

Perak MB denies PRN speculation

Heritage / 4mth

Sarawak Delta elevated to UNESCO-status global geo-park site

Malaysia / 5mth

Bersatu sacking: Leaders from Perak top the list

Opinion / 8mth

Football: An unforgiving business that requires long-term investments, professional management, and financial losses

People / 9mth

Father earning RM2,600 a month makes heart-breaking decision to send his kids to home

Spotlight

Malaysia

DAP NS throws support behind Loke, urges him to stay as chief

Malaysia

Tuanku Muhriz urges MB, assemblymen to uphold loyalty to royal institution

Opinion

Negeri Sembilan election: Just a return to historical trends

Malaysia

Ismail Lasim sworn in as Negeri Sembilan's 12th Menteri Besar

Opinion

Negeri Sembilan has spoken. Now, there must be humility to listen

By Vinod Sekhar

Malaysia

Viral Port Klang road rage video prompts police probe into street altercation

Malaysia

Selangor to overhaul stray animal enforcement procedures after dog's death sparks investigation

You may be interested

Malaysia

PRNNS: Amanah, Bersatu draw blanks in Negeri Sembilan as incumbents fall

Malaysia

Monday a state holiday for Negeri Sembilan - new MB

Malaysia

Hamzah invites ex-Bersatu members to Wawasan as party's relevance questioned after poll defeat

Malaysia

Malaysian suspected of heading human trafficking ring held in Thailand after alleged bribery attempt

Malaysia

DPM II Fadillah Yusof to undergo heart bypass surgery at IJN

Malaysia

Melaka BN opens door to 'BN Plus' talks after Negeri Sembilan poll success

Malaysia

Two teen girls held over armed condominium robbery in KL

Malaysia

Najib must be held accountable for 1MDB's US$5.6 billion loss -  lawyer