Malaysia

Consider targeted fuel mechanism’s impact on M40, govt told

Explore other means of cushioning impact of rising crude oil prices, some opposition lawmakers say

Updated 1 year ago · Published on 25 May 2022 8:00AM

Consider targeted fuel mechanism’s impact on M40, govt told
Elopura Warisan rep Calvin Chong Ket Kiun says there are simpler options that the government could subscribe to if they want to cushion the sharp jump in the projected fuel subsidy cost without affecting the lower income group, which includes increasing road tax charges for luxury vehicles. – SYEDA IMRAN/The Vibes pic, May 25, 2022

by Rebecca Chong

KOTA KINABALU – While a targeted fuel mechanism may seem like a good idea to cushion the impact of rising crude oil prices and protect the lower-income group, some are questioning if it is even doable.  

Elopura Warisan rep Calvin Chong Ket Kiun said that the government might have to fork out even more money to develop the proper system to implement such a mechanism.  

“How is the government going to implement the mechanism? Our gas station does not have the system. (Yet) they want the gas station to identify which car is eligible to get subsidised fuel, and keep the record?  

Wouldn’t this system encourage the stealing of subsidised fuel? Or wouldn’t gas stations cheat the system? How are they going to avoid this? 

“It might be a good idea, but for now, I don’t think it is doable,” he told The Vibes.  

Chong said there are simpler options that the government could subscribe to if they want to cushion the sharp jump in the projected fuel subsidy cost without affecting the lower income group.

This includes increasing road tax charges for luxury vehicles, or providing vouchers for vehicles with smaller engine capacity for gas allowances for a year, which can be distributed to the people when they renew their road tax annually.  

Elopura Warisan rep Calvin Chong Ket Kiun says that the government might have to fork out even more money to develop the proper system to implement such a targeted fuel mechanism. – Calvin Chong Facebook pic, May 25, 2022
Elopura Warisan rep Calvin Chong Ket Kiun says that the government might have to fork out even more money to develop the proper system to implement such a targeted fuel mechanism. – Calvin Chong Facebook pic, May 25, 2022

Meanwhile, Kota Kinabalu DAP MP Chan Foong Hin said that he disagrees with International Trade and Industry Minister Datuk Seri Mohamed Azmin Ali when he suggested that BMW drivers do not deserve fuel subsidy.  

“Discriminating the people against their vehicles is not helping anyone,” he said.  

Chan said not only the lower-income group is suffering from the increasing cost of living today, but those from the M40 have had to also reduce their expenses.  

In fact, he said, the wealth curve between the B40 and M40 has flattened a lot, as the M40 continues to be punished for their perceived wealth.  

“The M40 is already excluded from many other aid (schemes). Why make their lives more difficult? 

Instead of limiting or restricting fuel subsidy by vehicles according to their perceived luxuriousness, I would like to suggest the honourable minister to instead look at other ways to tax those whose extreme wealth is certain, such as those in the T20 bracket. 

“Maybe increase the tax rate to be imposed on the T1 to T20 group through their income tax. 

“Wouldn’t that be a much better way instead of targeting the general masses, the general hardworking people of Malaysia in the B40 and M40 group?” he said.  

Kota Kinabalu DAP MP Chan Foong Hin says the wealth curve between the B40 and M40 has flattened a lot, as the M40 continues to be punished for their perceived wealth. – Roket Kini pic, May 25, 2022
Kota Kinabalu DAP MP Chan Foong Hin says the wealth curve between the B40 and M40 has flattened a lot, as the M40 continues to be punished for their perceived wealth. – Roket Kini pic, May 25, 2022

Consumer Chan Tzun Hei also opined that the problem with the mechanism is that it is neglecting the M40 group.  

He said that the government must not forget that between BMW and Kancil, there are also Toyota, Honda, and Nissan – essentially middle-range cars.  

Between T20 and B40, there is also M40 that needs to be assisted. Those in M40 are the ones who are unable to enjoy the increase in minimum wages, nor are they able to apply for government assistance funds such as the Bantuan Prihatin Nasional.  

“They are the group that can easily fall into B40 but are struggling hard to climb up to T20,” he said.  

Chan also said the implementation of the mechanism may face several problems.

He illustrated the issue using a scenario in which a rich man who is able to own a BMW chooses to ride a Kancil to fill up the vehicle with cheaper gas.  

“What if a Kancil owner sells petrol to a BMW owner with a slightly higher ‘margin profit’ price? How do we tackle such crimes? In the end, it all depends on implementation,” he said. – The Vibes, May 25, 2022

Related News

World / 4mth

WHO chief calls for full medical, fuel aid access to Gaza 'now'

Malaysia / 5mth

DAP punishing two Sabah ‘Datuk’ recipients disrespectful: GRS

Malaysia / 5mth

Nation’s subsidies predicted to surpass RM81 bil this year: PM

Malaysia / 8mth

‘Sabah Water Dept, private suppliers in cahoots during water cuts?’

Malaysia / 9mth

Formulation of targeted subsidy mechanism for petrol not easy: Anwar

Malaysia / 10mth

Endlessly salty water has Sandakan residents at wits’ end

Spotlight

Events

UK alumni lauded for stellar achievements as British Council observes 75 years in Malaysia

Malaysia

Don’t let politicians, activists stir up hatred against KK Mart, PBK tells cops

By The Vibes Team

Malaysia

7.7 mil people registered in Padu, 2.5 mil cyberattacks, but not one success: Rafizi

By Stephen Then

Malaysia

Farewell Aunty Bersih, you will be missed

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Couple make two trips to workshop to find trapped kitten in car

Malaysia

KK Mart founder, director charged with wounding religious feelings of others over 'Allah' socks

By The Vibes Team

You may be interested

Malaysia

Blanket of red as tens of thousands of jellyfish washed ashore at KK beach

By The Vibes Team

Malaysia

Nuzul Al-Quran: PM calls on Muslims to analyse, interpret the Quran

Malaysia

MCA Youth latest to condemn petrol bomb attack at KK Mart outlet

By The Vibes Team

Malaysia

Anwar receives courtesy call from Indian External Affairs Minister

Malaysia

Sabah polls: We will let BN leadership decide on partners, says Bung

By Jason Santos

Malaysia

Penang’s iconic Komtar set to undergo major make-over

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Muhyiddin files for leave to review Court of Appeal ruling reinstating power abuse charges

Malaysia

Unfair for government to deny rakyat subsidies based on Padu registration, says SUPP youth

By Stephen Then