World

Diplomatic dilemma for Indonesia in accepting Chinese coronavirus vaccines

Analysts concerned Beijing may use vaccine donations as leverage to advance regional agenda

Updated 5 years ago · Published on 10 Dec 2020 6:30PM

Diplomatic dilemma for Indonesia in accepting Chinese coronavirus vaccines
Accepting access to the inoculations could implicate dependence on the Chinese medical supply chain in the long run. – AFP pic, December 10, 2020

JAKARTA – Indonesia is betting that China-made coronavirus vaccines can help it tackle one of the worst Covid-19 outbreaks in Asia, but analysts warn it is a wager that could leave them holding a high-interest diplomatic IOU.

Beijing has promised poorer nations priority access to its inoculations, in an attempt to repair an image tarnished by the pandemic, which started in the central Chinese city of Wuhan.

This week, Indonesia received 1.2 million doses of a Covid-19 vaccine made by China’s Sinovac with another 1.8 million set to arrive next month, but experts say this access could have strings attached.

“China’s ‘vaccine diplomacy’ is not unconditional,” said Ardhitya Eduard Yeremia and Klaus Heinrich Raditio in a paper published this month by the Singapore-based Yusof Ishak Institute.

“Beijing may use its vaccine donations to advance its regional agenda, particularly on sensitive issues such as its claims in the South China Sea.”

Indonesia started human trials of the Sinovac vaccine this summer, and it has not yet been approved by Chinese or Indonesian regulators.

Jakarta has signed deals for more than 350 million vaccine doses from different suppliers, including AstraZeneca, but the majority will come from Chinese suppliers, including Sinovac and Sinopharm, according to a Duke University vaccine-tracking project.

“The vaccine cooperation with China is the most high profile,” said Evan Laksmana, a senior researcher at the Jakarta-based Centre for Strategic and International Studies.

“That creates potential implications down the line (and) to what extent Indonesia would be highly dependent on the Chinese medical supply chain in the long run.”

Indonesia, the world’s fourth-most populous nation with 270 million people, has reported more than half a million coronavirus infections and around 18,000 deaths. Low testing rates means these official figures are widely thought to be well below the reality.

China is Indonesia’s top trading partner and the Southeast Asian nation is home to numerous projects, including a high-speed train line, that are part of Beijing’s globe-spanning Belt and Road infrastructure building blitz.

However, the relationship has its problems.

In January, Indonesia deployed fighter jets and warships to patrol the Natuna islands after Chinese coast guard and fishing vessels entered the area on the edge of the South China Sea.

Jakarta has since toned down its response, turning to diplomatic protests instead.

The United States views Jakarta as a key strategic partner as it pushes back against China’s growing influence and controversial military build-up in the South China Sea.

“At the moment, Indonesia is playing a rather clever balancing game in order to avoid identification with just one of the two great powers,” said Marcus Mietzner, an associate professor at Australian National University.

“(Indonesia) has already made it known that it would not accept a potential Chinese request to build a military base in Indonesia. While it is not clear whether China actually made such a request, its rejection was noted with great satisfaction in Western capitals.”

But with the US epidemic surging, Washington is focused on fighting the coronavirus at home and may not be able to knock Beijing off its vaccine diplomacy blitz.

And despite some disputes, the relationship with China remains crucial for Jakarta, and it may find itself indebted diplomatically to Beijing because of the vaccines.

“So far, there is yet to be any serious quid pro quo with regards to the vaccine,” said researcher Laksmana.

“But everyone in Jakarta is aware... It would be harder for us to make a series of moves in foreign policy or something else that might (damage) the relationship with China.” – AFP, December 10, 2020

Related News

Education / 1w

Malaysia must embrace AI in education to avoid falling behind

Malaysia / 2w

Police investigate personnel accused of insulting local community while travelling in China

Malaysia / 2w

Controversy in China, woman comes forward to apologise (video)

Malaysia / 3w

Comedian calls out viral behaviour of Malaysians abroad, questions ‘erosion of shame’ in social media age (video)

Malaysia / 3w

Malaysian tourists spark backlash in China over alleged rude behaviour (video)

Malaysia / 3w

The twilight of the university

Spotlight

Opinion

When bullying turns violent, Malaysia must confront what is happening inside schools

By The Vibes Says

Malaysia

Malaysia-Thailand open historic border crossing to deepen trade, regional integration

By Ian McIntyre

Malaysia

Gerak Khas drama actress, Tisha Samsir denies drug involvement

Malaysia

Student stabbing: Teenage girl sent to Hospital Bahagia for psychiatric evaluation

Malaysia

Anwar wishes Tun M a happy 101st birthday

World

Israel shares intelligence with US over alleged Iranian plot to assassinate Trump

Malaysia

EPF members withdraw RM19.87 billion from Flexible Account as of May 31

Malaysia

Melaka: Student who was allegedly bullied chases schoolmate with box cutter

World

Fresh US-Iran strikes deepen Middle East crisis as ceasefire crumbles

You may be interested

World

Amnesty calls for war crimes probe into Israeli strikes in Lebanon that allegedly killed entire families

World

China flood death toll rises to 39 in Guangxi as rescue teams race against further typhoon threat

World

Cargo plane wreckage found off Pakistan as search for 5 crew members continues

World

Fresh US-Iran strikes deepen Middle East crisis as ceasefire crumbles

World

AI set to reshape nearly 80 million jobs across Southeast Asia without mass layoffs

World

Sri Lanka moves to ease prison overcrowding after deadly Negombo riot kills 28

World

Fujian shoe factory fire kills 28 as China orders full investigation into deadly blaze

World

Fresh US strikes on Iran deepen ceasefire crisis as Trump warns of escalation